U S J P
M L
NITED TATES UDICIAL ANEL
ON
ULTIDISTRICT ITIGATION
Multidistrict Litigation
Terminated Through September 30, 2010
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
GRAND TOTALS (1,111 Litigations) 60,640 17,585 66,816 11,409 70 in 2010
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
090 DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA (33 Litigations)50 Ampicillin AT Richey, C.R. 16 45 61 0 198454 Alsco-Harvard Fraud Oberdorfer, L.F. 8 1 9 0 1983105 National Student Marketing Parker, B.D. 7 4 11 0 1983135 Mutual Fund Sales AT Corcoran, H.F. 43 4 47 0 1975205 Griseofulvin AT Robinson, Jr., A.E. 2 1 3 0 1978213 Radiation Incident - 4/5/74 CD Hart, Jr., G.L. 1 6 7 0 1978221 Saigon, S. Vietnam AD Oberdorfer, L.F. 32 14 42 4 1986258 Government Employees Insurance Co. SEC Hart, Jr., G.L. 2 2 4 0 1978283 Taipei Airport - 7/31/75 AD Bryant, W.M. 4 1 5 0 1981328 Amoxicillin PAT & AT Richey, C.R. 5 1 2 4 1984330 Swine Flu Immunization PL Gesell, G.A. 1,585 20 306 1,299 1988344 General Aircraft Corp. AT Green, J.L. 1 1 2 0 1979372 Federal Election Campaign Richey, J.L. 17 2 19 0 1979389 Barrow, AK - 10/13/78 AD Robinson, Jr., A.E. 3 1 4 0 1980458 Riyadh Airport, Saudi Arabia - 8/19/80 AD Flannery, T.A. 38 8 46 0 1982499 Washington, DC - 1/13/82 AD Green, J.H. 33 50 83 0 1988565 Korean Airlines - 9/1/83 AD Robinson, Jr., A.E. 160 54 129 85 1999613 GM 1980 X-Body Car PL Jackson, T.P. 1 1 2 0 1995688 Williams PAT Green, J.H. 1 2 3 0 1987886 United Mine Workers Hogan, T.F. 12 9 21 0 2001910 Freedom Magazine IRS/FOIA Sporkin, S. 8 0 8 0 1993
1034 Fialuridine ("FIAU") PL Lamberth, R.C. 6 4 10 0 20011163 Consumer Credit Counseling Services AT Urbina, R.M. 2 1 3 0 19991271 U.S. Office Products Co. SEC Urbina, R.M. 12 5 17 0 20041279 Tobacco/Governmental Health Care Costs Friedman, P.L. 33 3 36 0 20051284 Vitamin AT Hogan, T.F. 65 19 82 2 20101290 Lorazepam and Clorazepate AT Hogan, T.F. 7 7 14 0 20071307 Columbia/HCA Healthcare Co. Qui Tam (No. II) Lamberth, R.C. 30 0 26 4 20091686 Iraq and Afghanistan Detainees Hogan, T.F. 4 0 4 0 20071772 Series 7 Broker Qualifications Exam Scoring Bates, J.D. 13 8 21 0 20081792 InPhonic, Inc., Wireless Phone Rebate Huvelle, E.S. 10 5 15 0 20101796 Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Data Theft Robertson, J. 3 2 5 0 2010
1798 Long-Distance Telephone Service Federal Urbina, R.M. 3 1 4 0 2008Excise Tax
TOTAL 2,167 282 1,051 1,398
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 2
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
FIRST CIRCUIT
100 MAINE (2 Litigations)904 Asta Medica, S.A./Pfizer, Inc. Hornby, D.B. 4 1 5 0 1993
1361 Compact Disc Minimum Advertised Price AT Hornby, D.B. 55 1 56 0 2007
101 MASSACHUSETTS (40 Litigations)32 Revenue Properties Company, Ltd., SEC Caffrey, A.A. 19 13 32 0 197269 CBS Color Tube PAT Caffrey, A.A. 1 4 4 1 197478 Kauffman Mutual Fund AT Pettine, R.J. (RI) 9 1 10 0 1972122 Evergreen Valley Project SEC Bownes, H.H. (NH) 1 3 3 1 1977138 Viatron Computer Systems Corp. SEC Tauro, J.L. 2 3 5 0 1982160 Boston, MA - 7/31/73 AD Nelson, D.S. 46 17 49 14 1982197 Susquehanna Corporation SEC Frankel, M.E. (NYS) 3 1 1 3 1983443 Standard Screws AT Caffrey, A.A. 15 7 22 0 1982584 Atlantic Financial Management SEC Skinner, W.J. 4 26 29 1 1993672 TWA Hikacking - 6/14/85 Mazzone, A.D. 10 3 13 0 1993674 Recycling Equipment Investment Plans Harrington, E.F. 5 4 9 0 1992675 Elscint, Ltd., SEC Keeton, R.E. 3 3 6 0 1989696 Hubless Coupling AT Zobel, R.W. 1 1 2 0 1990705 Plastic Bag PAT & AT Mazzone, A.D. 1 1 2 0 1988713 First Commodity of Boston SEC Wolf, M.L. 23 22 45 0 1993730 Gillette Co./Pereleman SEC Tauro, J.L. 6 5 11 0 1988754 American Saw & Manufacturing TDMK Nelson, D.S. 3 1 4 0 1989852 Lomas Financial Corp. SEC Caffrey, A.A. 7 3 10 0 1993964 Computervision Corp. SEC Young, W.G. 3 14 17 0 1997
1007 RTC/Tully Plesser Fraudlent Transfer Zobel, R.W. 3 1 4 0 19951105 New England Mutual Life Insurance Co. Keeton, R.E. 22 9 30 1 20041111 Indigo N.V. SEC Young, W.G. 7 2 9 0 19971143 Mutual Life Insurance Co. of NY Harrington, E.F. 22 1 23 0 20091157 Fidelity Magellan Fund/Micron Stearns, R.G. 2 14 16 2000
Technologies, Inc., SEC1185 Sears, Roebuck and Co. Bankruptcy Saris, P.B. 2 5 6 1 19991195 Summit Technology, Inc., SEC Tauro, J.L. 1 17 18 0 20011238 Nabumetone PAT Lindsay, R.C. 1 3 4 0 20011376 Zonolite Attic Insulation PL Saris, P.B. 3 4 7 0 20061380 Xcelera.com Inc. SEC Zobel, R.W. 14 6 20 0 20081400 Pharmatrak, Inc., Privacy Tauro, J.L. 6 1 7 0 20041430 Lupron Marketing & SP Stearns, R.G. 10 7 17 0 2007
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 3
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
FIRST CIRCUIT(continued)
1461 Shell Oil Products Co. Dealer Franchise Zobel, R.W. 2 1 3 0 20091522 Edgartown, MA - 10/6/00 Tauro, J.L. 1 6 7 0 20051543 Carbon Black AT Woodlock, D.P. 7 9 16 0 20081592 Columbia University PAT Wolf, M.L. 5 5 10 0 20051713 Bank of America ATM Fee Saris, P.B. 2 1 3 0 20071753 Standard Automotive Corp. Retiree Gertner, N. 1 1 2 0 2008
Benefits "ERISA"1820 Webloyalty.com, Inc., Marketing & SP Tauro, J.L. 1 4 5 0 20091838 The TJX Companies, Inc., Customer Data Young, W.G. 19 10 29 0 2010
Security Breach1870 Greenwood Credit Union Prescreening Tauro, J.L. 2 1 1 2 2008
102 NEW HAMPSHIRE (4 Litigations)43 Hanover, NH - 10/25/68 AD Bownes, H.H. 24 14 38 0 1973132 Burlington, VT - 12/6/70 AD Coffrin, A.W. 3 1 4 0 1975876 Craig/Sterling Asset Devine, S. 1 1 2 0 1994
1140 Presstek, Inc., SEC Keeton, R.E. 1 7 8 0 2000
104 PUERTO RICO (7 Litigations)47 San Juan, PR - 3/5/69 AD Weinfeld, E. 19 24 43 0 1977721 Dupont Plaza, Puerto Rico Fire - 12/31/86 Acosta, R.L. 11 275 286 0 2005828 "SEA BARGE 101" Fuste, J.A. 5 2 7 0 1992925 American Airlines Flight 1473 - 8/28/91 AD Acosta, R.L. 7 11 12 6 1995
1077 American Airlines Flight 1555 - 10/31/93 AD Fuste, J.A. 3 1 3 1 19971156 Pepsi-Cola Puerto Rico Bottling Co. SEC Dominguez, D.R. 7 2 9 0 19991284 American Airlines Flight 574 In Flight Acosta, R.L. 3 9 12 0 2001
Engine Fire - 7/9/98
TOTAL 438 589 996 31
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 4
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SECOND CIRCUIT
205 CONNECTICUT (21 Litigations)45 Master Key AT Blumenfeld, M.J. 13 3 16 0 197796 Tweed New-Haven Airport - 6/7/71 AD Blumenfeld, M.J. 4 16 17 3 1976150 Petroleum Products AT Clarie, T.E. 2 1 3 0 1976297 Helicopter Crash in Germany - 9/26/75 AD Burns, E.B. 10 5 15 0 1981447 Cuisinart Food Processor AT Cabranes, J.A. 10 4 14 0 1984524 St. Croix, U.S. VI - 7/15/80 AD Zampano, R.C. 1 2 3 0 1987621 U.S. Surgical Corp. SEC Dorsey, P.C. 1 1 2 0 1986654 General Electric SEC Eginton, W.W. 4 1 5 0 1986708 Sobstad Sail PAT Daly, T.F. 6 1 7 0 1988712 Boardwalk Marketplace SEC Eginton, W.W. 180 152 332 0 1995844 Perrier Bottled Water PL Daly, T.F. 15 1 16 0 1993946 Colonial Realty Limited Partnerships Covello, A.V. 87 36 123 0 2001
1062 Stratford, CT - 4/27/94 AD Nevas, A.H. 5 6 11 0 19981180 Dubrovnik, Croatia - 4/3/96 AD Covello, A.V. 24 19 43 0 20021210 SmithKline Beecham Labs Billings Practices Covello, A.V. 6 5 11 0 20011241 Fine Host Corp. SEC Hall, J.C. 1 13 14 0 20011463 Xerox Corp. SEC Thompson, A.W. 1 21 22 0 20091505 Cardiac Devices Qui Tam Dorsey, P.C. 34 1 35 0 20071568 Parcel Tanker Shipping Services AT Covello, A.V. 9 9 18 0 20091572 Castellon, Spain - 10/10/01 AD Eginton, W.W. 5 5 9 1 20061649 Helicopter Crash Near Wendle Creek, Underhill, S.R. 3 2 5 0 2010
British Columbia - 8/8/02
206 NEW YORK, NORTHERN (2 Litigations)71 Welch & Morgan Port, E. 2 1 3 0 1975
1028 State of NY Claims on Abandoned Deposits Munson, H.G. 2 2 4 0 1999
207 NEW YORK, EASTERN (35 Litigations)147 Staines, England - 6/18/72 AD Weinstein, J.B. 5 10 15 0 1977196 Franklin National Bank SEC Weinstein, J.B. 4 13 16 1 1980227 John F. Kennedy Airport - 6/24/75 AD Brumwell, H. 84 66 149 1 1983295 Westinghouse Electric Corp. Weinstein, J.B. 5 3 8 0 1982331 Wiring Device AT Weinstein, J.B. 27 11 38 0 1980367 Cutter Laboratories, Inc. Weinstein, J.B. 24 4 28 0 1980
"Braumwald-Cutter" Aortic Heart Valve PL381 "Agent Orange" PL Weinstein, J.B. 605 26 629 2 2010
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 5
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SECOND CIRCUIT(continued)
441 Warsaw, Poland - 3/14/80 AD Sifton, C.P. 14 17 31 0 1986530 Malaga, Spain - 9/13/82 AD Nickerson, E.H. 37 93 130 0 1988582 Markeel Leasing Corp. Weinstein, J.B. 1 1 2 0 1990637 Energy Systems Equip SEC Wexler, L.D. 8 5 12 1 1991727 Athens, Greece - 4/2/86 AD Weinstein, J.B. 8 2 9 1 1991731 Tax Refund Platt, Jr., T.C. 4 1 5 0 1992778 Ambassador Group, Inc. Dearie, R.J. 2 2 4 0 1994787 Warsaw, Poland - 5/9/87 AD Nickerson, E.H. 3 22 25 0 1998792 Lietz Autofocus SLR PAT Mishler, J. 1 4 5 0 1989843 Cove Neck, NY - 1/25/90 AD Platt, Jr., T.C. 59 142 201 0 2000846 Dime Savings of New York SEC (No. II) Mishler, J. 4 3 7 0 1994963 Pan Am/Delta Pilot Employment EP Weinstein, J.B. 1 1 2 0 1997
1059 MTC Technologies Co. Ltd. SEC Gleeson, J.H. 1 13 14 0 20061090 Arakis Energy Corp. SEC Ross, A.R. 8 18 26 0 20031116 Playmobil, USA, Inc., AT Seybert, J. 2 1 3 0 20011119 Tower Air Flight 41 Incident - 12/20/03 Gleeson, J.H. 15 44 59 0 20031124 Acclaim Entertainment, Inc., SEC Platt, Jr., T.C. 1 17 18 0 19981208 Sterling Foster & Co., Inc., SEC Spatt, A.D. 8 5 12 1 20071211 Toys "R" Us, Inc., AT Gershon, N. 31 7 38 0 20001234 Cityscape Financial Corp. SEC Johnson, Jr., S. 1 11 12 0 20011344 Nantucket Island, MA - 10/31/99 AD Block, F. 67 31 91 7 20051362 CINAR Corp. SEC Dearie, R.J. 2 7 9 0 20031383 Ciprofloxacin Hydrochloride AT Trager, D.G. 30 5 35 0 20051408 Tamoxifen Citrate AT Glasser, I.L. 18 12 30 0 20031587 JetBlue Airways Corp. Privacy Amon, C.B. 2 12 14 0 20051613 Nigeria Charter Flights CONT Dearie, R.J. 6 8 14 0 20091689 Air Crash Near Woodbury, CT - 12/20/02 Sifton, C.P. 7 1 8 0 20071844 Air Crash Near Peixoto de Azeveda, Cogan, B.M. 65 5 70 0 2008
Brazil - 9/29/06
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 6
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SECOND CIRCUIT(continued)
208 NEW YORK, SOUTHERN (122 Litigations)9 Protection Devices AT Metzner, C.M. 16 68 84 0 1977
10 Antibiotic Drug (Settling Cases) AT Wyatt, I.B. 116 41 94 0 197710 Antibiotic Drug AT Lord, M.W. (MN)
(Non-settling actions reassigned) 0 0 63 0 1977(Non-settling cases reassigned and dismissed) 0 10 10 0 1977
37 Seeburg-Commonwealth United Merger McFadden, F.H. (ALN) 14 13 27 0 198056A Penn Central Commercial Paper Edelstein, D.N. 11 35 17 8 1975
(Reassigned to NYS tr'or judges) 0 0 21 061 Carrom TDMK Tyler, Jr., H.R. 3 1 4 0 197467 Brown Co. SEC Rubin, A.B. (LAE) 2 3 5 0 197375 Value Line Special Situations SEC Tenney, C.H. 1 3 4 0 197987 Madison Fund SEC Tyler, Jr., H.R. 3 10 13 0 1974100 Texas Gulf Sulphur SEC Bonsal, D.B. 1 70 71 0 1975110 Caesars Palace SEC Weiner, C.R. (PAE) 2 9 11 0 1975113 Atlantic Dept. Stores SEC Weiner, C.R. (PAE) 5 4 9 0 1974126 Stirling Homex Corp. SEC Bonsal, D.B. 29 2 30 1 1982127 General Adjustment Bureau AT Werker, H.F. 3 1 2 2 1978133 Stirling Homex Banking SEC Bonsal, D.B. 3 1 4 0 1975157 Scientific Control Corp. SEC Brieant, Jr., C.L. 2 2 4 0 1975170 Molinaro/Catanzaro PAT Metzner, C.M. 12 2 5 9 1975174 Republic National-Realty Equities SEC Pollack, M. 5 14 18 1 1978192 Amerada Hess Corp. AT Cannella, J.M. 2 2 4 0 1981229 Ionian Sea - 9/8/74 AD Duffy, K.T. 8 24 32 0 1981246 Haven Industries SEC Gagliardi, L.P. 1 1 1 1 1980251 Generics Corp. SEC Pierce, L.W. 3 3 6 0 1979264 Colocotronis Tanker SEC Tenney, C.H. 4 3 7 0 1978290 Investors Funding Corp. of NY SEC Conner, W.C. 5 8 13 0 1986306 Tenerife, Canary Islands - 3/27/77 AD Ward, R.J. 159 15 141 33 1979314 New York City Municipal SEC Owen, R. 3 10 13 0 1985
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 7
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SECOND CIRCUIT(continued)
321 Sunshine Mining SEC Knapp, W. 1 3 4 0 1981334 Amtel, Inc., SEC Goettel, G.L. 3 4 7 0 1981358 Amman, Jordan - 9/23/77 AD Broderick, V.L. 4 2 6 0 1982395 Ocean Shipping AT Stewart, Jr., C.E. 20 18 38 0 1983406 Resource Exploration, Inc., SEC Brieant, Jr., C.L. 7 3 10 0 1986433 St. Croix, VI - 7/24/79 AD Weinfeld, E. 6 1 7 0 1982451 Shopping Carts AT Brieant, Jr., C.L. 25 21 46 0 1987487 The Stoffer Corp. Building Fire - 12/4/80 CD Sofaer, A. 2 22 23 1 1984494 AM International, Inc., SEC Sprizzo, J.E. 6 10 16 0 1987549 Amarex SEC Leval, P.N. 4 5 9 0 1988556 Providence, RI - 2/21/82 AD Sand, L.B. 1 1 2 0 1984579 AMERICAN LANCER Damaged Cargo Leval, P.N. 1 24 25 0 1990581 Baldwin-United Corp. Brieant, Jr., C.L. 88 41 129 0 1991602 British Airways Food Incidents - 3/84 Knapp, W. 11 7 18 0 1987620 Corporate Communications Consultants PAT Sprizzo, J.E. 21 2 10 11 1991
(Reassigned to NYS tr'or judge) 0 0 2 0626 Union Carbide, Bhopal, India - 12/84 CD Keenan, J.F. 83 19 102 0 1992649 E.F. Hutton Banking SEC Knapp, W. 10 6 16 0 1991665 Gas Reclamation SEC Sand, L.B. 16 18 33 1 1993669 Provincetown-Boston, Inc., Airline SEC Stewart, C.E. 1 1 2 0 1989692 Union Carbide Consumer Products Business SEC Brieant, Jr., C.L. 1 3 4 0 1990724 Hijacking in Pakistan - 9/5/86 Sprizzo, J.E. 70 28 98 0 1997732 Ivan F. Boesky SEC Pollack, M. 19 22 41 0 1997735 Wedtech Corp. SEC Sand, L.B. 4 21 25 0 1995750 Transpac SEC Griesa, T.P. 2 3 5 0 1994759 Z.L. Commercial Services/Global Cable CONT Sprizzo, J.F. 1 1 2 0 1991760 "Apollo" AT & CONT Pollack, M. 61 2 63 0 1991774 Nifedipine Capsule PAT Keenan, J.F. 3 2 5 0 1990777 Stuart R. Myers PAT Owen, R. 4 2 6 0 1991
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 8
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SECOND CIRCUIT(continued)
806 Dun & Bradstreet Edelstein, D.N. 2 2 4 0 1993811 Ross Capital Corp. SEC Keenan, J.F. 1 4 5 0 1992818 RJR Nabisco, Inc., SEC Mukasey, M.B. 3 8 11 0 1994856 Lou Levy & Sons Fashions, Inc. Griesa, T.P. 4 1 5 0 1993869 First American Center SEC Brieant, C.L. 2 0 2 0 1994872 Del-Val Financial Corp. SEC Conner, W.C. 7 5 12 0 1996873 McDonnell Douglas Equipment Leasing SEC Cannella, J.M. 1 2 3 0 1994890 General Development Corp. SEC McKenna, L.M. 1 2 3 0 1993897 Integrated Resources Real Estate SEC Sweet, R.W. 10 40 50 0 1996902 Consolidated Welfare Fund "ERISA" Pollack, M. 31 6 12 25 1998913 American Business Computers SEC Brieant, C.L. 1 3 4 0 1995924 Michael Milken SEC Pollack, M. 80 38 116 2 1998933 Salomon Brothers Treasury SEC Patterson, Jr., R.P. 4 40 44 0 1998948 Industrial Diamond AT Conner, W.C. 2 2 4 0 2002989 Northwest Airlines Incident, Patterson, Jr., R.P. 3 1 4 0 1995
Tokyo, Japan - 9/19/91 AD994 Towers Financial Noteholders SEC Knapp, W. 5 15 20 0 2000
1005 Prudential Securities, Inc., L.P. Program SEC Pollack, M. 20 5 25 0 19991023 NASDAQ Market-Maker AT & SEC Sweet, R.W. 25 6 31 0 20041064 D. Blech & Co. SEC Sweet, R.W. 2 8 10 0 20041065 Sunrise Group Ltd. Mortgage Note McKenna, L.M. 66 1 67 0 2000
Security Agreement1115 MG Refining & Marketing CONT Casey, R.C. 2 17 19 0 19991153 Bennett Funding Group SEC (No. II) Duffy, K.T. 34 32 66 0 20091154 New Balance Athletic Shoe, Inc., AT Sweet, R.W. 1 1 2 0 19971160 Ford Motor Credit Co. CONT Martin, Jr., J.S. 4 1 5 0 19991161 Long Island, NY - 7/17/96 AD Sweet, R.W. 99 110 209 0 20031222 Oxford Health Plans, Inc., SEC Brieant, C.L. 44 12 56 0 20031230 Philip Services Corp. SEC Hellerstein, A.K. 10 14 24 0 20071258 Mezzonen, S.A., SEC McKenna, L.M. 1 1 2 0 20041283 Stock Exchanges Options Trading AT Casey, R.C. 17 13 30 0 20011330 Utilities Uranium Decomtamination and Cote, D. 3 1 1 3 2002
Decommissioning Fund1336 Abercrombie & Fitch Co. SEC Griesa, T.P. 15 5 20 0 20091339 United Parcel Service, Inc., Excess Value Berman, R.M. 25 1 26 0 2004
Insurance Coverage1348 Rezulin PL Kaplan, L.A. 1,853 15 1,868 0 2009
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 9
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SECOND CIRCUIT(continued)
1352 DoubleClick Inc. Privacy Buchwald, N.R. 2 10 12 0 20011368 High Pressure Laminate AT Brieant, C.L. 7 30 37 0 20071374 Assicurazioni Generali S.p.A. Holocaust Mukasey, M.B. 33 3 36 0 2005
Era Insurance1386 European Rail Pass AT Conner, W.C. 6 16 22 0 20031410 Buspirone PAT Koeltl, J.G. 3 1 4 0 20031413 Buspirone AT Koeltl, J.G. 29 5 34 0 20051428 Ski Train Fire in Kaprun, Austria - 1/11/00 Scheindlin, S.A. 13 15 28 0 20081443 America Online, Inc., Community Leaders Duffy, K.T. 2 1 3 0 20101448 Belle Harbor, NY - 11/12/01 AD Sweet, R.W. 218 158 376 0 20101472 Global Crossing, Ltd., SEC & "ERISA" Lynch, G.E. 65 24 88 1 20091484 Merrill Lunch & Co., Inc., Research Reports SEC Keenan, J.F. 41 135 176 0 20081487 Worldcom, Inc., SEC & "ERISA" Cote, D. 153 24 177 0 20091495 Enterprise Mortgage Acceptance Co. SEC Kram, S.W. 4 9 13 0 20071500 AOL Time Warner Inc. SEC McMahon, C. 42 30 72 0 20101513 Wireless Telephone Services AT Cote, D. 7 1 8 0 20071554 Initial Public Offering (IPO) SEC Scheindlin, S.A. 1 510 511 0 20101598 Ephedra PL Rakoff, J.S. 687 173 855 5 20091628 Pineapple AT Berman, R.M. 4 6 10 0 20101630 Global Crossing Limited SEC Lynch, G.E. 5 4 9 0 20071644 Elevator and Escalator AT Griesa, T.P. 13 12 25 0 20091659 Nortel Networks Corp. SEC Preska, L.A. 1 28 29 0 20101661 Rivastigmine PAT Baer, Jr., H. 3 2 5 0 20091695 Veeco Instruments Inc. SEC McMahon, C. 11 2 13 0 20081696 Sierra Wireless, Inc., SEC Stein, S.H. 2 7 9 0 20071706 Doral Financial Corp. SEC Rakoff, J.S. 3 22 25 0 20081714 Rhodia S.A. SEC Batts, D.A. 3 1 4 0 20081739 Grand Theft Auto Video Game Consumer (No. II) Sullivan, R.J. 3 5 8 0 20101740 Canon U.S.A., Inc. Digital Cameras PL Rakoff, J.S. 2 2 4 0 20071744 Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc., SEC McMahon, C. 3 7 10 0 20101750 Sony BMG Audio Compact Disc Buchwald, N.R. 3 9 12 0 20061755 Bayou Hedge Funds Investment McMahon, C. 4 6 10 0 20091771 "A Million Little Pieces" Holwell, R.J. 8 3 11 0 20081780 Digital Music AT Preska, L.A. 24 7 31 0 20091794 Novartis Wage and Hour Rakoff, J.S. 1 2 3 0 20091903 PepsiCo, Inc., Bottled Water Marketing & SP Seibel, C. 3 2 5 0 2009
TOTAL 6,260 3,261 9,399 122
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 10
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
THIRD CIRCUIT
311 DELAWARE (15 Litigations)46 Frost PAT Wright, C. 2 6 8 0 1976301 Salisbury, MD - 5/16/74 AD Layton, III, C.R. 1 2 3 0 1978401 Cole PAT Stapleton, W.K. 1 2 3 0 1983507 Arab Boycott Latchum, J.L. 3 1 4 0 1984573 Phillips Petroleum PAT Longobardi, J.J. 1 5 6 0 1989623 Convertible Rowing Exerciser PAT Longobardi, J.J. 10 3 13 0 1994720 General Motors Class E SEC Robinson, S.L. 9 2 11 0 1993722 CPC International SEC Farnan, Jr., J.J. 2 4 6 0 1989
1228 Manchak PAT Robinson, S.L. 12 2 14 0 20031232 Warfarin Sodium AT Robinson, S.L. 5 4 8 1 20021304 Reliance Acceptance Group, Inc., SEC Farnan, Jr., J.J. 10 13 23 0 20031660 PharmaStem Therapeutics, Inc., PAT Sleet, G.M. 5 1 6 0 20101866 Brimonidine PAT Sleet, G.M. 1 1 2 0 20101941 Alfuzosin Hydrochloride PAT Sleet, G.M. 1 4 5 0 20101949 Rosuvastatin Calcium PAT Farnan, Jr., J.J. 2 8 10 0 2010
312 NEW JERSEY (43 Litigations)16 Fourth Class Postage Regulations Augelli, A.T. 10 11 21 0 1972247 Fireman's Fund Insurance Co. Debevoise, D.R. 1 1 2 0 1985300 Ciba-Geigy Corp. PAT Meanor, H.C. 4 2 6 0 1977393 General Public Utilities SEC Sarokin, H.L. 1 3 4 0 1983414 Corn Derivatives AT Debevoise, D.R. 33 3 36 0 1986461 Amtrak-Linden, NJ - 7/9/80 CD Fisher, C.S. 5 6 7 4 1985496 Caesars World Shareholders SEC Brotman, S.S. 12 2 14 0 1982618 Newark, NJ Texaco Explosion - 1/7/83 CD Debevoise, D.R. 2 3 5 0 1987729 Zenith Labs., Inc., SEC Debevoise, D.R. 1 9 10 0 1990747 Gibson Alleged Kickback Brown, Jr., G.E. 1 1 2 0 1988858 Passover Matzo AT Ackerman, H.A. 1 3 4 0 1992864 Donald J. Trump Casino SEC Gerry, J.F. 6 3 9 0 1992914 Volcano Energy Systems, Inc., CONT & PAT Sarokin, H.L. 3 1 1 3 1992920 Pantopaque PL Lifland, J.C. 32 3 35 0 2001962 Hibbard Brown & Co. SEC Thompson, A.E. 32 6 38 0 1998975 Campbell Soup Co. Retiree Medical Brotman, S.S. 4 1 5 0 1997
Benefits "ERISA"992 Republic Waste Industries, Inc., SEC Brotman, S.S. 1 1 2 0 1995
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 11
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
THIRD CIRCUIT(continued)
1061 Prudential Insurance Co. Sales Practices Wolin, A.M. 331 10 330 11 20041102 Sun Life Assurance Co. of Canada Politan, N.H. 5 4 9 0 19991112 Ford Motor Co. Ignition Switch PL Simandle, J.B. 14 3 13 4 20031123 Amoco Corp. Gasoline Advertising Orlofsky, S.M. 3 2 5 0 19971177 Research Corp. Technologies PAT Brown, Jr., G.E. 4 1 5 0 20001188 Mid-American Waste Systems, Inc., SEC Bassler, W.G. 3 1 1 3 19991213 Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Co. Debevoise, D.R. 2 1 3 0 20001235 American Family Publishers Business Practices Politan, N.H. 44 2 46 0 20021247 Medical Resources, Inc., SEC Walls, W.H. 7 7 14 0 20031292 Cendant Corp. SEC Walls, W.H. 11 7 18 0 20101337 Holocaust Era German Industry, Bank & Insurance Debevoise, D.R. 37 22 55 4 20081399 AT&T Corp. SEC Brown, Jr., G.E. 17 11 12 16 20061445 Mirtazapine PAT Hochberg, F.S. 4 9 13 0 20041471 Compensation of Managerial, Professional and Brown, Jr., G.E. 2 2 4 0 2010
Technical Employees AT1514 Electrical Carbon Products AT Simandle, J.B. 13 12 25 0 20091540 MOSAID Technologies, Inc., PAT Martini, W.J. 1 1 1 1 20051550 IDT Corp. Calling Card Terms Wigeton, S.D. 3 2 5 0 20081777 SFBC International, Inc., SEC & DER Chesler, S.R. 7 7 14 0 20081799 Vonage Initial Public Offering (IPO) SEC Wolfson, F.L. 1 15 16 0 20101850 Pet Food PL Hillman, N.L. 89 31 120 0 20091851 Desloratadine PAT Cooper, M.L. 3 1 4 0 20101857 Schering Marketing and SP (No. II) Chesler, S.R. 4 2 6 0 20101881 Boscov's Department Store, LLC, Fair and Accurate Irenas, J.E. 2 1 3 0 2009
Credit Transactions Act (FACTA)1938 Vytorin/Zetia Marketing, SP and PL Cavanaugh, D.M. 95 42 137 0 20101956 Toshiba America HD DVD Marketing and SP Debevoise, D.R. 4 2 6 0 20102006 Chrysler LLC 2.7 Liter V-6 Engine Oil Sludge PL Hochberg, F.S. 7 1 8 0 2010
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 12
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
THIRD CIRCUIT(continued)
313 PENNSYLVANIA, EASTERN (69 Litigations)3 Plumbing Fixtures AT Harvey, II, A. (MD) 375 14 389 0 1978
10 Antibiotic Drug AT (Group III) Weiner, C.R. 1 9 10 0 198112 Concrete Pipe (East of the Rockies) AT Davies, J.M. 25 13 38 0 197156 Penn Central SEC Lord, III, J.S. 63 27 90 0 197959 CBS Licensing AT Troutman, E.M. 2 1 3 0 1975115 REA Express, Inc., AT Becker, E.R. 12 2 14 0 1977119 Professional Hockey AT Higginbotham, Jr., A.L. 8 5 13 0 1974125 Pellston, MI - 5/9/70 AD Higginbotham, Jr., A.L. 3 2 5 0 1974134 Pittsburgh & Lake Erie R.R. SEC & AT Troutman, E.M. 7 2 9 0 1978189 Japanese Electronic Products AT Becker, E.R. 1 1 2 0 1986
201A Sugar Industry (East Coast) AT Cahn, E.N. 14 26 40 0 1981257 Ironworkers Union EP Hannum, J.B. 2 2 2 2 1980323 "Fine Paper" AT McGlynn, J.L. 41 9 50 0 1981360 Gas Meter AT Weiner, C.R. 6 3 9 0 1980364 Philadelphia, PA - 6/23/76 AD Newcomer, C.C. 2 15 17 0 1980368 Food Fair SEC Huyett, III, D.H. 3 3 6 0 1980379 Water Heater AT Ditter, Jr., J.W. 7 27 34 0 1982467 Arthur Treacher's Franchise Hannum, J.B. 7 10 17 0 1982475 Glassine & Greaseproof Paper AT Weiner, C.R. 1 8 9 0 1981546 Catanella & E.F. Hutton Giles, J.T. 5 4 9 0 1988555 Mannheim, Germany - 9/11/82 AD Weiner, C.R. 11 44 55 0 1986587 Lake Erie Iron Ore AT Fullam, J.P. 11 0 11 0 1991607 Towner Petroleum Co. SEC Van Artsdalen, D.W. 12 2 14 0 1988611 Cape Henry, VA - 3/20/83 AD Weiner, C.R. 2 1 3 0 1985619 Cable/Tel. Corp & Entities SEC Bechtle, L.C. 1 2 3 0 1985633 Real Estate Title AT Van Artsdalen, D.W. 7 6 13 0 1986655 Sunrise Savings & Loan SEC O'Neill, Jr., T.N. 4 13 17 0 1994681 First Jersey SEC Weiner, C.R. 23 5 28 0 1990685 Montgomery Ward Catalog Green, C.S. 43 3 42 4 1991739 Matthews & Wright SEC Huyett, III, D.H. 3 4 7 0 1995745 Continental Banks/S. Somerman & Entities Newcomer, C.C. 1 2 3 0 1989764 Texas Eastern Transmission Corp. Van Artsdalen, D.W. 1 3 4 0 1993
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 13
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
THIRD CIRCUIT(continued)
768 Bexar County Health SEC Bechtle, L.C. 2 1 3 0 1990784 Suzuki Samurai PL Fullam, J.F. 8 10 18 0 1990797 Delco Wire and Cable Co. Van Artsdalen, D.W. 1 1 2 0 1991849 Bolar Pharmaceutical Co., Inc. Cahn, E.N. 2 1 3 0 1992938 Unisys Corp. Long Term Disability Plan Buckwalter, R.L. 1 1 2 0 1996943 Conrail/Teamsters 1992 Boycott Bechtle, L.C. 7 1 8 0 1994961 General Motors Corp. Pick-Up Yohn, Jr., W.H. 17 9 26 0 1994
Truck Fuel Tank PL1014 Orthopedic Bone Screw Buckwalter, R.L. 2,812 273 1,800 1,251 2010
(Reassigned to PAE tr'or judge) 0 0 34 01039 Residential Doors AT Broderick, R.J. 2 4 6 0 19981100 Loewen Group, Inc., SEC O'Neill, T.N. 1 2 3 0 19981127 Foundation for New Era Philanthropy Dalzell, S. 1 6 7 0 19981128 Painted Aluminum Products AT Pollak, L.H. 1 2 3 0 19991148 Latex Gloves PL Ludwig, E.V. 548 72 55 502 2004
(Reassigned to PAE tr'or judge) 0 0 63 01155 Cyber Promotions, Inc., Electronic Mail Weiner, C.R. 1 2 3 0 19971219 Aetna, Inc., SEC Padova, J.R. 3 2 5 0 20011233 Advanta National Bank Credit Card Terms Robreno, E.C. 8 1 9 0 20021239 Chrysler Corp. Vehicle Paint Van Antwerpen, F.S. 1 1 2 0 20001244 Graphite Electrodes AT (No. II) Shapiro, N.L. 5 20 25 0 20071261 Linerboard AT DuBois, J.E. 13 7 20 0 20091269 Peggy's Cove, Nova Scotia - 9/2/98 AD Giles, J.T. 292 5 288 9 20051273 LifeUSA Holdings, Inc., Annuity Contracts Joyner, J.C. 3 1 4 0 2004
Sales Practices (No. II)1280 Loewen Group, Inc., SEC (No. II) O'Neill, T.N. 7 13 20 0 20011301 Providian Financial Corp. Credit Card Terms Yohn, Jr., W.H. 6 4 10 0 20021318 IKON Office Solutions, Inc., SEC Katz, M. 2 16 18 0 20021324 Comox Lake, British Columbia - 10/30/97 Bechtle, L.C. 4 2 6 0 20011353 NCO Financial Systems, Inc., Debt Collection Robreno, E.C. 1 1 2 0 20021360 Rite Aid Corporation SEC Dalzell, S. 2 21 23 0 20031402 Microcrystallline Cellulose AT O'Neill, Jr., T.N. 6 11 17 0 2007
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 14
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
THIRD CIRCUIT(continued)
1426 Automotive Refinishing Paint AT Surrick, R.B. 42 21 63 0 20101498 Laughlin Products, Inc., PAT Baylson, M.M. 65 2 67 0 20061655 USF Red Star Inc. Worker Notification Tucker, P.B. 2 3 5 0 20061675 ACE Limited SEC Savage, T.J. 3 1 4 0 20091741 Isolagen, Inc., SEC & DER Buckwalter, R.L. 3 2 5 0 20091768 Methyl Methacrylate (MMA) AT Savage, T.J. 5 13 18 0 20101879 Sterling Financial Corp. SEC Stengel, L.F. 4 5 9 0 20091904 OSI Restaurant Partners, LLC, Fair and Accurate O'Neill, Jr., T.N. 2 2 4 0 2009
Credit Transactions Act (FACTA)1955 Orleans Homebuilders, Inc., Fair Labor DuBois, J.E. 1 1 2 0 2009
Standards Act (FLSA)
314 PENNSYLVANIA, MIDDLE (4 Litigations)293 Anthracite Coal AT Muir, M. 10 5 10 5 1979652 Rope AT Conaboy, R.P. 7 4 11 0 1991999 Sensible Grammar Software CR Caldwell, W.C. 1 1 2 0 1995
1556 Pressure Sensitive Labelstock AT Vanaskie, T.I. 10 1 11 0 2010
315 PENNSYLVANIA, WESTERN (15 Litigations)74 Suess PAT Rosenberg, L. 12 2 14 0 1979109 Glenn W. Turner Enterprises SEC Weber, G.J. 47 2 34 15 1982390 Pittsburgh, PA - 8/21/77 AD McCune, B.P. 5 5 7 3 1983536 Bituminous Coal Wage Bloch, A.N. 23 13 19 16 1991
(Reassigned to PAW tr'or judge) 0 0 1 0833 Integrated Resources Commercial Paper SEC Ziegler, D.E. 4 1 5 0 1993860 Allegheny International Inc. SEC Lewis, T.K. 5 5 10 0 1993905 Construction Industries "ERISA" Standish, W.L. 4 9 13 0 1993959 Phar-Mor, Inc., SEC Ziegler, D.E. 38 16 54 0 1997982 Chambers Development Co. SEC Lee, D.J. 2 22 24 0 1998
1040 Pittsburgh, PA - 9/8/94 AD Standish, W.L. 19 47 62 4 20001068 Mercedes-Benz of North America EP Standish, W.L. 3 4 7 0 20001091 Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. Sales Practices Ambrose, D.W. 76 72 148 0 20071200 Flat Glass AT Ambrose, D.W. 13 21 33 1 20061220 Ferrosilicon Products AT Lancaster, G.L. 1 6 7 0 19991503 Advanced Investment Management, L.P., Cindrich, R.J. 8 2 10 0 2004
Pension Management
TOTAL 5,803 1,362 5,306 1,859
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 15
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
FOURTH CIRCUIT416 MARYLAND (21 Litigations)
36 Kaehni Jewelry PAT Northrop, E. 6 3 9 0 1972267 Independent Gasoline AT Young, J.H. 3 4 7 0 1981284 Practice of Naturopathy Young, J.H. 29 1 30 0 1979444 1980 Decennial Census Northrop, E.S. 40 0 39 1 1989456 Mid-Atlantic Toyota AT Young, J.H. 9 2 11 0 1985552 Goldsboro, MD - 1/15/80 AD Howard, J.C. 1 1 1 1 1985728 Chase, MD Rail Collision - 1/4/87 CD Harvey, II, A. 66 26 92 0 1990780 Sabin Oral Polio Vaccine PL Motz, J.F. 7 1 7 1 1995824 RAC Mortgage Investment SEC Motz, J.F. 1 4 5 0 1993827 Lone Star Industries Concrete R.R. Ties PL Harvey, II, A. 5 4 9 0 1993922 Trans-Pacific Insurance Co. Nickerson, W.M. 3 1 4 0 1993
1069 American Honda Dealer Relations Motz, J.F. 77 21 97 1 20011110 Second Chance Body Armor, Inc., Advertising Davis, A.M. 7 2 9 0 20071120 ABF Freight System, Inc., CONT Harvey, II, A. 4 1 5 0 19981332 Microsoft Corp. Windows Operation Systems AT Motz, J.F. 111 6 117 0 20101387 ProteGen Sling and Vessica Systems PL Legg, B.E. 573 11 582 2 20101388 Cruciferous Sprout PAT Nickerson, W.M. 4 2 6 0 20051421 Wireless Telephone Radio Frequency Blake, C.C. 16 3 17 2 2007
Emissions PL1518 Allegheny Energy, Inc., SEC Davis, A.M. 14 3 17 0 20071539 Royal Ahold N.V. SEC and "ERISA" Blake, C.C. 33 4 37 0 20101982 Tyson Foods, Inc., Chicken Raised Without Bennett, R.D. 9 3 12 0 2010
Antibiotics Consumer
417 NORTH CAROLINA, EASTERN (4 Litigations)802 Applied Crane, Inc., CONT Fox, J.C. 1 1 2 0 1989929 Food Lion, Inc., Scheduling EP Fox, J.C. 8 3 9 2 1998
1132 Exterior Insulation Finish System PL Britt, W.E. 101 8 79 30 20081634 Peanut Crop Insurance Howard, M.J. 16 1 17 0 2007
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 16
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
FOURTH CIRCUIT(continued)
418 NORTH CAROLINA, MIDDLE (5 Litigations)232 Joseph F. Smith PAT Ward, H.H. 3 3 6 0 1979868 Andarko Oil & Gas SEC Tilley, Jr., N.C. 4 1 5 0 1993987 Actionquest, Inc., Boating Accident Osteen, Sr., W.L. 2 2 4 0 1995
1084 Morrisville, North Carolina - 12/13/94 AD Bullock, Jr., F.W. 9 1 2 8 19991622 Cotton Yarn AT Beaty, Jr., J.A. 1 8 9 0 2009
419 NORTH CAROLINA, WESTERN (7 Litigations)13 Hendersonville, NC - 7/19/67 AD Jones, W.W. 2 99 101 0 1971202 Charlotte, NC - 9/11/74 AD McMillan, J.B. 15 5 19 1 1977209 Panty Hose Seaming PAT Jones, W.W. 7 2 9 0 1977574 Yarn Processing PAT (No. II) McMillan, J.B. 23 6 29 0 1988932 Southeast Hotel Properties SEC Potter, R.D. 2 2 4 0 1995
1516 Polyester Staple AT Voorhees, R.L. 23 13 36 0 20081558 Charlotte, NC - 1/8/03 AD Mullen, G.C. 7 3 10 0 2006
420 SOUTH CAROLINA (7 Litigations)1041 Charlotte, NC - 7/2/94 AD Anderson, Jr., J.F. 25 44 66 3 19971378 Safety-Kleen Corp. SEC Anderson, Jr., J.F. 1 20 21 0 20051397 Laidlaw Inc. SEC Anderson, Jr., J.F. 1 4 5 0 20051612 The Thaxton Group Inc. SEC Anderson, Jr., G.R. 4 2 2 4 2006865 Showa Denko K.K. L-Tryptophan PL (No. II) Perry, Jr., M.J. 856 117 456 416 2007
(Reassigned to SC tr'or judges) 0 0 101 01429 American General Life & Accident Currie, C.M. 106 29 135 0 2007
Insurance Co. Industrial Life Insurance1595 Electrical Receptacle PL Blatt, Jr., S. 5 4 9 0 2007
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 17
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
FOURTH CIRCUIT(continued)
422 VIRGINIA, EASTERN (10 Litigations)188 Industrial Wine Contracts SEC MacKenzie, J.A. 1 7 8 0 1977195 Eastern Air Lines Flight Attendant Weight EP Merhige, Jr., R.R. 2 1 1 2 1978199 Upperville, VA - 11/27/73 AD Bryan, Jr., A.V. 8 41 49 0 1977235 Westinghouse Electric Corp. Uranium CONT Merhige, Jr., R.R. 12 1 13 0 1981244 Western Electric Co., Inc., Semiconductor PAT Warriner, D.D. 5 1 6 0 1978544 Action Industries SEC Williams, R.L. 3 1 4 0 1984680 Epic Mortgage Insurance Hilton, C.M. 4 2 6 0 1988
1113 Apple Juice PL Spencer, J.R. 13 0 13 0 19991174 America Online, Inc., Unlimited Access Brinkema, L.M. 19 7 26 0 19981705 Xybernaut Corp. SEC Brinkema, L.M. 7 3 10 0 2008
423 VIRGINIA, WESTERN (1 Litigation)1198 Dun & Bradstreet, Inc., Debt Kiser, J.L. 3 2 4 1 2002
Collection Practices
424 WEST VIRGINIA, NORTHERN (1 Litigation)280 Underprivileged Students Haden, II, C.H. 1 1 2 0 1978
425 WEST VIRGINIA, SOUTHERN (4 Litigations)39 Silver Bridge Disaster CD Kaufman, F. (MD) 26 30 56 0 197594 Huntington, WV - 11/14/70 AD Hall, K.K. 21 4 25 0 1973
1477 Serzone PL Goodwin, J.R. 172 5 177 0 20071617 Maytag Corp. Neptune Washer PL Goodwin, J.R. 4 1 5 0 2005
TOTAL 2,541 588 2,654 475
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 18
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
FIFTH CIRCUIT
53l LOUISIANA, EASTERN (30 Litigations)159 Plywood AT Pointer, Jr., S.C. (ALN) 22 9 31 0 1983252 Liquid Carbonic Truck Drivers Sear, M.L. 14 21 35 0 1978
Chemical Poisoning281 Ascot Oils, Inc., SEC Schwartz, C. 2 1 3 0 1983392 Continental Grain Disaster CD Mitchell, L.L. 6 1 7 0 1980417 Marine Construction AT Sear, M.L. 65 12 76 1 1986481 Incident Aboard the D/B OCEAN KING - Beer, P.H. 2 7 9 0 1982
8/30/80 CD508 OCEAN RANGER Sinking Off Collins, R.F. 63 26 89 0 1986
Newfoundland - 2/15/82 CD516 New Orleans, LA - 7/9/82 AD Duplantier, A.G. 49 253 256 38 1988
(Reassigned to LAE tr'or judge) 0 0 8 0622 M/V ANTACUS - 7/6/84 CD Arceneaux, Jr., G. 3 5 8 0 1987738 PENROD, in Gulf of Mexico - 10/27/85 CD Beer, P. 2 29 31 0 1988863 Taxable Municipal Bond SEC Sear, M.L. 44 2 41 5 1996867 Prudential-Bache Energy Growth Funds SEC McNamara, A.J. 9 15 24 0 1993888 Prudential-Bache Energy Income Livaudais, M. 6 5 11 0 1994
Partnerships SEC991 Ford Motor Co. Bronco II PL Sear, M.L. 6 2 7 1 1998
1063 Ford Motor Co. Vehicle Paint PL Vance, S.S. 8 1 9 0 20001098 Masonite Corp. Hardboard Siding PL Feldman, M.L.C. 43 1 41 3 20031149 New York Life Insurance Co. Sear, M.L. 4 2 6 0 19971181 Air Bag PL Feldman, M.L.C. 1 2 3 0 19981193 Bank of Lousiana/Kenwin Shops, Inc., CONT Duval, Jr., S.R. 3 2 5 0 20001298 Papst Licensing, GmbH, PAT Barbier, C.J. 6 1 7 0 20031321 MasterCard International, Inc. Internet Gambling Duval, Jr., S.R. 14 0 14 0 20041322 VISA International Association Internet Gambling Duval, Jr., S.R. 19 0 19 0 20041371 Monumental Life Insurance Co. Industrial Feldman, M.L.C. 13 1 14 0 2007
Life Insurance1382 Unitrin, Inc., Industrial Life Insurance Barbier, C.J. 85 6 89 2 20061390 Life Insurance Co. of Georgia Industrial Feldman, M.L.C. 129 4 125 8 2009
Life Insurance
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 19
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
FIFTH CIRCUIT(continued)
1391 American Life Insurance Co. Industrial Feldman, M.L.C. 3 1 4 0 2005Life Insurance
1395 Western & Southern Life Insurance Co. Feldman, M.L.C. 8 0 8 0 2007Industrial Life Insurance
1531 Train Derailment Near Amite, LA - 10-12/02 Zainey, J.C. 3 39 42 0 20061632 High Sulphur Content Gasoline PL Lemelle, I.L.R. 3 16 19 0 20061643 Educational Testing Service PLT 7-12 Test Scoring Vance, S.S. 27 4 31 0 2008
53N LOUISIANA, MIDDLE (2 Litigations)282 So. Central States Bakery Products AT Schwartz, C. (LAE) 5 1 6 0 1982979 Combustion Inc. Hazardous Haik, Sr., R.T. (LAW) 3 17 20 0 1994
Waste Substances Cleanup
536 LOUISIANA, WESTERN (3 Litigations)193 Natchitoches Parish, LA - 9/20/73 AD Dawkins, Jr., B.C. 6 1 7 0 1979353 Marsh Island, LA - 12/8/77 AD Davis, W.E. 2 22 24 0 1981615 Helicopter Crash Near Lake Charles, LA - Veron, E.E. 1 1 2 0 1989
9/15/83 AD
537 MISSISSIPPI, NORTHERN (1 Litigation)928 Catfish/Catfish Products AT Davidson, G.H. 6 7 13 0 1997
538 MISSISSIPPI, SOUTHERN (3 Litigations)1183 Cheminova, Inc., Insecticide PL Gex, III, W.J. 1 3 4 0 19981209 Progressive Games, Inc., PAT Wingate, H.T. 13 3 16 0 20001872 Wayne Farms LLC Fair Labor Standards Act Starrett, K. 11 2 13 0 2010
539 TEXAS, NORTHERN (22 Litigations)80 Las Vegas, NV - 10/8/68 AD Hill, R.M. 10 5 5 10 197484 Mandeville, LA - 1/8/71 AD Brewster, L. 1 1 2 0 1974101 Camco PAT Brewster, L. 1 1 1 1 1975248 Beef Industry AT Kazen, G.P. (TXS) 17 7 24 0 1989260 Ownership of Longoria Bank Deposits Hughes, S.T. 2 1 2 1 1978
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 20
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
FIFTH CIRCUIT(continued)
261 Municipal Bond Reporting AT Taylor, Jr., W.M. 2 1 3 0 1980
371 LTV SEC Higginbotham, P.E. 5 3 8 0 1982560 Letterman Brothers SEC Hill, R.M. 1 3 3 1 1984562 Camp LeJeune, NC - 5/22/81 AD Fish, A.J. 2 2 4 0 1987596 Spanish Internation Communications AT Belew, Jr., D.O. 6 2 8 0 1987628 Cotton AT Woodward, H.O. 6 3 9 0 1988634 Academy Life Insurance Co. Sanders, B. 5 6 11 0 1988657 Dallas/Fort Worth Airport - 8/2/85 AD Belew, Jr., D.O. 61 35 63 33 1993761 "SABRE" Air Reservation AT & CONT Buchmeyer, J. 13 121 134 0 1993771 Texarkana, TX - 4/4/86 AD Buchmeyer, J. 5 1 6 0 1990772 Incepts, Inc., inTIME License Maloney, R.B. 3 4 7 0 1991903 Texas Municipalities/Southwestern Bell Maloney, R.B. 2 2 4 0 1996
Telephone Company Fee Ordinance1019 Dallas/Fort Worth Airport - 4/14/93 AD Fitzwater, S.A. 3 0 1 2 19951214 Great Southern Life Insurance SP Fitzwater, S.A. 24 1 25 0 20081528 Southwestern Life Insurance Co. Sales Practices Sanders, B. 12 0 12 0 20061578 UICI "Association Group" Insurance Fish, A.J. 29 0 28 1 20101627 American Airlines, Inc., Privacy Fitzwater, S.A. 3 2 5 0 2006
540 TEXAS, EASTERN (6 Litigations)187 L.E. Lay & Co., Inc., AT Justice, W.W. 1 1 2 0 1976790 Exxon Corp. Recoupment Parker, R.M. 15 17 32 0 1994
1038 Norplant Contraceptive PL Schell, R.A. 3,397 563 3,954 6 20021263 Alcaltel Alsthom SEC Brown, P.N. 23 2 25 0 20021512 Electronic Data Systems Corp. SEC & "ERISA" Davis, L.E. 5 24 29 0 20091530 Fleming Companies Inc. SEC & DER Ward, T.J. 7 15 22 0 2009
541 TEXAS, SOUTHERN (26 Litigations)27 WESTEC Corp. SEC Hannay, A.B. 4 31 35 0 1982253 Tenneco, Inc., SEC Singleton, Jr., J.V. 2 4 6 0 1978262 Southern Pacific Transportation Co. EP Stirling, R.N. 2 24 26 0 1984310 Corrugated Container AT Singleton, Jr., J.V. 55 26 80 1 1983366 Motion Picture Licensing AT Singleton, Jr., J.V. 6 2 5 3 1987398 Alien Children of Texas Education Seals, W.B. 7 14 14 7 1990
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 21
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
FIFTH CIRCUIT(continued)
429 Shannon, Ireland - 10/2/77 AD Bue, Jr. C.O. 3 1 4 0 1985440 International Systems & Controls Corp. SEC Black, N.W. 2 3 5 0 1984457 Ranger I Sinking-Galveston, TX - 5/10/79 CD Gibson, H. 9 13 22 0 1984489 Drilling Platform Blowout & Fire Gibson, H. 10 4 3 10 1984
in Gulf of Mexico - 3/24/80 CD (Reassigned to TXS tr'or judge) 0 0 1 0592 Sioux Ltd. SEC Black, N.W. 3 2 5 0 1987625 Houston Oil Trust SEC Bue, Jr., C.O. 1 20 21 0 1986746 TX Dept. of Corrections Inmate Trust Fund Black, N.W. 1 2 3 0 1992789 Triad SEC DeAnda, J. 13 7 7 10 1994
(Reassigned to TXS tr'or judge) 0 0 3 0791 Terra-Drill SEC Pollack, M. (NYS) 5 1 5 1 1990837 Granada Partnerships SEC Harmon, M. 3 1 2 2 1995
1035 Tucuti, Panama - 6/6/92 AD Rosenthal, L.H. 1 2 3 0 19961078 "RONFIN" Series C Bonds SEC Rosenthal, L.H. 2 1 3 0 19981096 Crown Life Insurance Co. Premium Lake, S. 35 30 63 2 20061206 Lease Oil AT (No. II) Jack, J.G. 13 2 13 2 19991422 Waste Management, Inc., SEC Harmon, M. 5 2 7 0 20071553 Silica PL Jack, J.G. 117 7 122 2 20061646 Testmasters TDMK Gilmore, V.D. 2 5 6 1 20091810 MERSCORP Inc., et al., Real Estate Settlement Jack, J.G. 30 0 28 2 2008
Procedures Act (RESPA)1886 Refined Petroleum Products AT Lake, S. 6 1 7 0 20091994 VistaPrint Corp. Marketing and SP Atlas, N.F. 6 1 7 0 2010
542 TEXAS, WESTERN (4 Litigations)155 Roadway Express EP Real, M.L. (CAC) 3 1 4 0 1981347 Commonwealth Oil/TESORO Petroleum SEC Higginbotham, P.E. (TXN) 3 2 5 0 1980605 Sani-Fresh Liquid Soap TDMK Prado, E.C. 2 1 3 0 1987919 Ramstein Air Base - 8/29/90 AD Sear, M.L. (LAE) 6 2 8 0 1995
TOTAL 4,728 1,560 6,132 156
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 22
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SIXTH CIRCUIT
643 KENTUCKY, EASTERN (2 Litigations)8A Cincinnati Airport - 11/8/65 AD Swinford, M. 6 2 8 0 19728B Cincinnati Airport - 11/21/67 AD Swinford, M. 47 14 24 37 1973
644 KENTUCKY, WESTERN (3 Litigations)683 Gander, Newfoundland - 12/12/85 AD Johnstone, E.H. 80 85 165 0 1991
1466 PrimeVision Health, Inc., CONT Russell, T.B. 8 2 10 0 20061998 Countrywide Financial Corp. Customer Data Russell, T.B. 36 2 38 0 2010
Security Breach
645 MICHIGAN, EASTERN (15 Litigations)
60 Willingham PAT Kaess, F.W. 1 3 4 0 1975184 Toilet Seat AT Keith, D.J. 8 3 11 0 1978266 Allegheny Beverage Corp. SEC Thornton, T.F. 2 1 2 0 1980
(Reassigned to MIE tr'or judge) 0 0 1 0343 Upjohn Co. Antibiotic "Cleocin" PL Kennedy, C.G. 12 1 2 10 1980
(Reassigned to MIE tr'or judge) 0 0 1 0505 Detroit, MI - 1/19/79 AD Feikens, J. 4 2 6 0 1984559 DeLorean Motor Co. Woods, G.E. 3 30 33 0 1991598 Long Distance Telecommunications Taylor, A.D. 19 0 19 0 1992742 Detroit, MI - 8/16/87 AD Cook, Jr., J.A. 55 114 169 0 1997
891 Detroit, MI - 12/3/90 AD Rosen, G.E. 9 29 37 1 19951044 Ford Motor Co. EP Friedman, B.A. 11 0 11 0 19981055 Rio Hair Naturalizer PL Rosen, G.E. 149 33 182 0 19981178 Monroe, MI - 1/7/97 AD Feikens, J. 27 7 30 4 20011278 Cardizem CD AT Edmunds, N.G. 21 4 24 1 20041725 Delphi Corp. SEC, DER & "ERISA" Rosen, G.E. 9 16 25 0 20091749 General Motors Corp. SEC & DER Rosen, G.E. 2 3 5 0 2009
646 MICHIGAN, WESTERN (3 Litigations)511 First Federal Savings and Loan (Niles, MI) Gibson, B.F. 2 16 16 2 1988
1122 Jackson National Life Insurance McKeague, D.W. 14 1 15 0 20051306 Nuway Paper Machinery CONT Bell, R.H. 2 1 3 0 2001
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 23
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SIXTH CIRCUIT(continued)
647 OHIO, NORTHERN (18 Litigations)76 Refrigerant Gas AT Battisti, F.J. 4 0 4 0 1976182 Triax Co. PAT Manos, J.M. 1 2 3 0 1982265 General Tire & Rubber Co. SEC Battisti, F.J. 3 2 5 0 1981345 Technicare Corp. SEC Manos, J.M. 1 3 4 0 1981436 Art Materials AT Krupansky, R.B. 24 0 24 0 1987601 Glass Tempering PAT Walinski, N.J. 9 1 10 0 1986650 Commons, Ltd., SEC Walinski, N.J. 1 3 4 0 1988673 Burger Chef Franchise Dowd, D.D. 59 7 66 0 1991723 Goodyear Tire & Rubber Bell, S.H. 2 3 5 0 1988776 Los Angeles, CA - 6/30/87 AD Batchelder, A. 4 4 7 0 1991
(Reassigned to OHN tr'or judge) 0 0 1 0851 Revco/Anac SEC Aldrich, A. 1 1 1 1 1994936 New York LaGuardia Airport - 3/22/92 AD Lambros, T.D. 18 39 54 3 1995996 White Consolidated Industries, Inc., Lambros, T.D. 1 1 2 0 1995
Environmental Insurance Coverage1256 East Side Mario's Franchise Nugent, D.C. 1 1 2 0 19991401 Sulzer Orthopedics Inc. Hip Prosthesis and O'Malley, K.M. 406 28 434 0 2009
Knee Prosthesis PL1481 Meridia PL Gwin, J.S. 94 32 126 0 20081488 Ford Motor Co. Panther Platform/ Nugent, D.C. 27 4 31 0 2008
Fuel Tank Design PL1593 Capital Consultants, LLC, "ERISA" Dowd, Jr., D.D. 5 3 7 1 2006
648 OHIO, SOUTHERN (16 Litigations)38 Dayton, OH - 3/9/67 AD Weinman, C.A. 6 9 13 2 1975420 Ohio River Disaster CD Porter, D.S. 8 5 13 0 1983486 Richardson-Merrell, Inc., "Bendectin" PL (No. II) Rubin, C.B. 629 560 910 279 1985606 D.H. Baldwin SEC Porter, D.S. 11 1 8 4 1987635 Montgomery, OH - 12/16/82 AD Spiegel, S.A. 5 8 13 0 1988
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 24
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SIXTH CIRCUIT(continued)
743 Keenan PAT Holschuh, J.D. 3 1 4 0 1988
744 "Jifflox" PL Graham, J.L. 63 18 27 53 1990(Reassigned to OHS tr'or judge) 0 0 1 0 1991
782 Chubb Corp. Drought Insurance Rubin, C.B. 23 2 25 0 1989850 Cordis Corp. Cardiac Pacemakers PL Rice, W.H. 23 2 25 0 1996887 Steel Drums AT Rubin, C.B. 8 6 14 0 1993921 Lipton Iced Tea Bottlers CONT Graham, J.L. 4 1 3 2 1993
1057 Telectronics Pacing Systems, Inc., Spiegel, S.A. 454 4 456 2 2003Accufix Atrial "J" Leads PL
1315 SmarTalk TeleServices, Inc., SEC Sargus, Jr., E.A. 3 18 20 1 20081393 Cooper Tire & Rubber Co. Tires PL Holschuh, J.D. 27 1 28 0 20031638 Foundry Resins AT Frost, G.L. 10 10 20 0 20091829 Vision Service Plan Tax Graham, J.L. 9 2 11 0 2010
649 TENNESSEE, EASTERN (2 Litigations)200 Chatanooga, TN - 11/27/73 AD Wilson, F.W. 2 6 6 2 1976
1552 UnumProvident Corp. SEC, DER and "ERISA" Collier, C.L. 14 14 22 6 2010
650 TENNESSEE, MIDDLE (7 Litgations)180 Warehouse Construction CONT Morton, L.C. 1 2 2 1 1977273 Amtrak Train Derailment at Morton, L.C. 2 4 6 0 1979
Frankewing, TN - 10/1/75 CD1031 Tennessee Public Indecency Statute Echols, T.A. 4 2 6 0 20001086 Krystal Co. EP Higgins, T.A. 3 1 4 0 19961227 Columbia/HCA Healthcare Corp. Higgins, T.A. 4 3 7 0 2003
Billing Practices1457 Allstate Insurance Co. Underwriting and Trauger, A.A. 9 2 11 0 2010
Rating Practices1537 Nortel Networks Corp. "ERISA" Nixon, J.T. 2 4 6 0 2010
651 TENNESSEE, WESTERN (3 Litigations)64 New Orleans (Moisant Field) - 3/20/69 AD McRae, R.M. 6 6 12 0 1971755 Citicorp Acceptance Co./Mobile McRae, R.M. 7 2 9 0 1994
Home Dealer1267 Edmondson Landfill & South 8th Street Landfill Donald, B.B. 2 6 8 0 2005
Superfund Site
TOTAL 2,530 1,203 3,321 412
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 25
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SEVENTH CIRCUIT
752 ILLINOIS, NORTHERN (61 Litigations)2 Children's Books AT Decker, B.M. 42 15 57 0 1971
21 Admission Ticket AT Robson, E.A. 10 2 12 0 197129 Butterfield PAT Will, H.L. 98 14 112 0 197358 Air Fare Will, H.L. 5 2 7 0 197365 Government Auto Fleet AT McGarr, F.J. 42 7 49 0 197799 Commodities Exchange Commission Rate AT Bauer, W.J. 3 5 8 0 1973108 Convenient Food Mart Franchise Marshall, P.H. 1 4 5 0 1975130 AMF Computerized Cash Register McLaren, R.W. 7 2 9 0 1977203 Mt. McKinley National Park, AK - 7/9/74 CD Decker, B.M. 7 1 8 0 1975223 TransOcean Tender Offer SEC Will, H.L. 2 1 3 0 1982250 Folding Carton AT Will, H.L. & Robson, E.A. 41 52 93 0 1981272 Potash Industry AT Marshall, P.H. 12 17 29 0 1978291 Cenco, Inc., SEC Aspen, M.E. 2 9 11 0 1992308 General Motors Corp. Engine Interchange McGarr, F.J. 13 4 16 1 1981342 Uranium Ind. AT Marshall, P.H. 4 2 6 0 1984374 Burlington Northern EP Leighton, G.N. 11 3 14 0 1984376 AMOCO CADIZ Oil Spill CD Norgle, Jr., C.R. 7 3 10 0 1992391 Chicago, IL - 5/29/79 AD Robson, E.A. & Will, H.L. 93 77 105 45 1985
(Reassigned to ILN tr'or judges) 0 0 20 0471 Lynn L. Augspurger PAT Grady, J.F. 1 1 2 0 1982534 Wheat Rail Freight Rate AT Marshall, P.H. 4 3 7 0 1984589 Giacomino CONT Getzendanner, S. 2 1 3 0 1986644 ContiCommodity SEC & CONT Hart, W.T. 16 10 26 0 1991704 Molitor PAT Moran, J.B. 5 2 7 0 1992810 Burger King CONT Nordberg, J.A. 2 1 3 0 1989817 Sioux City, IA - 7/19/89 AD Conlon, S.B. 44 18 62 0 1993847 VMS Real Estate SEC Zagel, J.B. 18 37 55 0 1999853 Mahurkar Double Lumen Hemodialysis PAT Easterbrook, F.H. 1 2 3 0 1994874 Clozapine AT Leinenweber, H.D. 35 1 36 0 1993899 Mortgage Escrow Deposit Zagel, J.B. 57 18 75 0 2008967 Lloyd's London/Cascade Helicopters, Inc. Holderman, Jr., J.F. 1 1 2 0 1995976 Fund F "ERISA" Zagel, J.B. 3 4 7 0 2001985 Scouring Pads AT Marovich, G.M. 6 7 13 0 1994
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 26
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SEVENTH CIRCUIT(continued)
997 Brand-Name Prescription Drugs AT Kocoras, C.P. 160 23 75 108 20051004 Abbott Laboratories Omniflox PL Aspen, M.E. 84 4 87 1 19981070 Roselawn, IN - 10/31/94 AD Castillo, R. 26 26 49 3 19981083 Amino Acid Lysine AT Shadur, M.I. 17 5 21 1 19971095 General Instrument Corp. SEC Leinenweber, H.D. 7 7 8 6 20011137 Bertelsmann Music Group Collection Letters Holderman, Jr., J.F. 2 3 5 0 19991150 CBC Companies, Inc., Collection Letters Bucklo, E.E. 3 1 3 1 20001175 Hooters, Inc., EP Manning, B.M. 1 2 3 0 19981182 Synthroid Marketing Bucklo, E.E. 46 2 48 0 20001192 GE Capital Corp. Bankruptcy Holderman, Jr., J.F. 5 4 9 0 1999
Debtor Reaffirmation1242 Sterling, Inc., Bankruptcy Debtor Aspen, M.E. 1 1 2 0 2001
Reaffirmation Agrements1266 General Motors Type III Door Latch PL Zagel, J.B. 2 1 3 0 20021329 RealNetworks, Inc., Privacy Kocoras, C.P. 5 2 7 0 20031350 Trans Union Corp. Privacy Gettleman, R.W. 13 2 15 0 20091403 StarLink Corn PL Moran, J.B. 25 5 29 1 20051412 America Online, Inc., Version 6.0 Software Anderson, W.R. 2 1 3 0 20061417 Amsted Industries Inc. "ERISA" Moran, J.B. 17 3 6 14 20091425 Aimster CR Aspen, M.E. 11 0 11 0 20091437 McDonald's Corp. Promotional Games Kennelly, M.F. 13 3 16 0 20041491 African American Slave Descendents Norgle, Sr., C.R. 8 2 10 0 20101521 Wireless Telephone 911 Calls Grady, J.F. 9 1 10 0 20091525 MLR, LLC PAT St. Eve, A.J. 2 1 3 0 20041773 Air Crash Near Athens, Greece - 8/14/05 Lindberg, G.W. 4 3 7 0 20071778 Ocean Financial Corp. Prescreening St. Eve, A.J. 5 1 6 0 20081783 JP Morgan Chase & Co. SEC Coar, D.H. 2 1 3 0 20101818 CitiFinancial Services Incorporated Holderman, Jr., J.F. 9 1 10 0 2009
Prescreened Offer1876 Long Beach Mortgage Company Truth in Lending Andersen, W.R. 2 1 3 0 2010
Act 1-4 Family Rider1893 RC2 Corp. Toy Lead Paint PL Leinenweber, H.D. 9 9 18 0 20091927 Texas Roadhouse Fair and Accurate Credit Norgle, Sr., C.R. 1 1 2 0 2010
Transactions Act (FACTA)
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 27
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
SEVENTH CIRCUIT(continued)
753 ILLINOIS, CENTRAL (3 Litigations)949 PS Group, Inc., SEC Baker, H.A. 3 2 5 0 1996
1087 Corn Sweeteners AT Mihm, M.M. 26 12 37 1 20051171 Ford Motor Anti-Lock Brake System PL Mihm, M.M. 1 1 2 0 1997
754 ILLINOIS, SOUTHERN (2 Litigations)1275 MCI Non-subscriber Telephone Rates Herndon, D.R. 8 1 9 0 20011562 General Motors Corp. Vehicle Cooling System PL Murphy, G.P. 11 2 11 2 2009
755 INDIANA, NORTHERN (1 Litigation)1767 H&R Block Mortgage Corp. Prescreening Lozano, R. J. 2 1 3 0 2008
756 INDIANA, SOUTHERN (8 Litigations)30 Fairland, IN - 9/9/69 AD Holder, C.J. 68 58 126 0 1972104 Aviation PL Sharp, M.E. (WAW) 13 3 16 0 1973557 Inwood, IN - 11/8/79 CD Noland, J.E. 11 5 16 0 1991907 Eli Lilly & Co. Prozac PL Dillin, S.H. 82 3 41 44 2000912 Recombinant DNA PAT & CONT Dillin, S.H. 3 3 5 1 1997
1310 Bromine AT Barker, S.E. 8 4 12 0 20051727 COBRA Tax Shelters Lawrence, W.T. 2 2 3 1 20101831 Orthopaedic Implant Device AT Tinder, J.D. 3 1 4 0 2008
757 WISCONSIN, EASTERN (4 Litigations)98 Career Academy AT Gordon, M.L. 4 2 6 0 1984140 Clark Oil & Refining AT Reynolds, J.W. 1 1 2 0 1977805 Balcor Film SEC Reynolds, J.W. 1 1 2 0 1992
1978 Velocity Express, Inc., Wage and Hour EP Griesbach, W.C. 9 1 10 0 2010
758 WISCONSIN, WESTERN (2 Litigations)998 Gross Common Carrier, Inc., Shabaz, J.C. 33 137 170 0 1994
Freight Undercharge Claims1303 Copper AT Crabb, B.B. 5 3 8 0 2001
TOTAL 1,380 685 1,835 230
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 28
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
EIGHTH CIRCUIT860 ARKANSAS, EASTERN (4 Litigations)
1049 Bus Accident at Faversham, Kent, Eisele, G.T. 6 0 6 0 1998England - 11/10/93 CD
1221 Case IH Cotton Picker PL Eisele, G.T. 64 18 82 0 20011282 Deere & Co. Cotton Picker Fire PL Eisele, G.T. 17 2 19 0 20021308 Little Rock, AR - 6/1/99 AD Eisele, G.T. 11 65 76 0 2003
861 ARKANSAS, WESTERN (1 Litigation)1832 Pilgrim's Pride Fair Labor Standards Act Barnes, H.F. 15 1 16 0 2010
862 IOWA, NORTHERN (2 Litigations)428 Iowa Beef Processors McManus, E.J. 3 2 4 1 1983957 Virginia Precast/Hydrotile Machinery SEC Melloy, M.J. 1 2 3 0 1994
863 IOWA, SOUTHERN (3 Litigations)165 Alodex Corp. SEC Hanson, W.C. 3 2 5 0 1978405 Deere & Co. Field Cultivator PAT Hanson, W.C. 2 1 3 0 1984
1733 Teflon PL Longstaff, R.E. 21 2 3 20 2009
864 MINNESOTA (24 Litigations)10 Antibiotic Drugs (Group 1) AT Lord, M.W. 10 57 58 0 1977
(Reassigned to PAE tr'e judge) 0 0 9 018 IBM AT Neville, P. 8 1 7 2 1973210 Celotex "Technifoam" PL Weiner, C.R. (PAE) 21 16 35 0 1985
(Reassigned to MN tr'or judges) 0 0 2 0242 Olympia Brewing Co. AT & CONT Weiner, C.R. (PAE) 4 61 65 0 1978454 Exterior Siding & Aluminium AT Weiner, C.R. (PAE) 3 1 4 0 1985517 Flight Transportation Corp. SEC Weiner, C.R. (PAE) 2 54 56 0 1985781 AT&T Equipment CONT Magnuson, P.A. 2 1 3 0 1993793 Wirebound Boxes AT Murphy, D.E. 5 3 8 0 1991973 Real Estate Appraiser AT Murphy, D.E. 3 2 5 0 1996981 Potash AT Kyle, R.H. 4 13 17 0 1997
1001 Temporomandibular Joint (TMJ) Implants PL Magnuson, P.A. 221 166 373 14 20031047 Piper Funds SEC Magnuson, P.A. 2 10 12 0 19971058 Airline Ticket Commission AT Rosenbaum, J.M. 15 20 35 0 19971186 Minnesota Mutual Life Insurance Co. Doty, D.S. 3 3 6 0 20011204 The Hartford Sales Practices Kyle, R.H. 2 1 2 1 20011246 Old Kent Mortgage Co. Doty, D.S. 4 1 5 0 2003
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 29
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
EIGHTH CIRCUIT(continued)
1309 Lutheran Brotherhood Variable Insurance Magnuson, P.A. 1 6 7 0 2005Products Co. Sales Practices
1328 Monosodium Glutamate AT Magnuson, P.A. 13 1 14 0 20071511 Xcel Energy, Inc., SEC, DER & "ERISA" Doty, D.S. 2 14 16 0 20051555 Operation of the Missouri River System Magnuson, P.A. 6 1 7 0 20051726 Medtronic, Inc., Implantable Defibrillators PL Rosenbaum, J.M. 273 932 1,191 12 2009
(Reassigned to MN tr'or judges) 0 0 2 01849 C.H. Robinson Worldwide, Inc., Overtime Pay Erickson, J.N. 75 27 102 0 20081892 KFC Corp. Fair Labor Standards Act Doty, D.S. 27 2 29 0 20091990 Northstar Education Finance, Inc., CONT Frank, D.W. 2 2 4 0 2010
865 MISSOURI, EASTERN (13 Litigations)216 Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. Harper, R.W. 4 2 6 0 1981
Maternity Benefits263 Falstaff Brewing Corp. AT Wangelin, H.K. 8 2 9 1 1978448 McDonnell Douglas Corp. SEC Hungate, W.L. 2 1 3 0 1984706 Hops AT Hungate, W.L. 3 4 7 0 1988740 Chrysler Overnight Evaluation Program Nangle, J.F. 72 8 71 9 1992
1033 Ticketmaster Corp. AT Limbaugh, S.N. 15 0 14 1 19961129 General Motors Corp. Anti-Lock Brakes PL Nangle, J.F. 10 2 12 0 20021179 General American Life Insurance Co. Perry, C.D. 37 1 38 0 20051264 BankAmerica Corp. SEC Nangle, J.F. 23 3 26 0 20031506 Charter Communications, Inc., SEC Shaw, C.A. 6 9 15 0 20051620 Metoprolol Succinate PAT Sippel, R.W. 4 4 8 0 20081702 Air Crash Near Kirksville, Missouri - 10/19/04 Hamilton, J.C. 3 9 12 0 20081907 Aurora Dairy Corp. Organic Milk Marketing & SP Webber, E.R. 17 2 19 0 2009
866 MISSOURI, WESTERN (12 Litigations)22A Grain Shipment CONT (No. II) Becker, W.H. 11 5 15 1 197477 International House of Pancakes AT Collinson, W.R. 10 9 18 1 197683 Midwest Milk Monopolization AT Oliver, J.W. 28 2 28 1 1982
(Reassigned to MOW tr'or judge) 0 0 1 0
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 30
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
EIGHTH CIRCUIT(continued)
111 Transit Co. Tire AT Hunter, E.B. 10 3 13 0 1980123 Cessna Aircraft Distributorship AT Roberts, R.T. 1 2 3 0 1987
217 Piper Aircraft Distribution System AT Sachs, H.F. 6 1 7 0 1984243 Warhead Explosion Aboard Collinson, W.F. 2 2 4 0 1977
USS Newport News - 10/1/72 CD362 Multi-Piece Rim PL Collinson, W.F. 45 9 13 34 1983
(Reassigned to MOW tr'or judge) 0 0 7 0679 Ethanol Plants SEC Sachs, H.F. 51 0 51 0 1995
1351 Fleming Companies, Inc., CONT Fenner, G.A. 2 3 4 1 20021559 Wireless Telephone Federal Cost Recovery Fees Gaitan, Jr., F.J. 25 2 27 0 20051786 H&R Block, Inc., Express IRA Marketing Dorr, R.E. 9 12 21 0 2010
867 NEBRASKA (2 Litigations)1597 Union Pacific Railroad Co. EP Camp, L.S. 3 1 4 0 20061920 Saturn L-Series Timing Chain PL Smith Camp, L. 2 1 3 0 2009
TOTAL 1,260 1,589 2,750 99
NINTH CIRCUIT
970 ARIZONA (13 Litigations)144 Coolidge, AZ - 5/6/71 AD Muecke, C.A. 3 17 20 0 1980296 Cement & Concrete AT Real, M.L. (CAC) 11 34 45 0 1985765 Dual-Deck Video AT Broomfield, R.C. 3 2 5 0 1993934 American Continental/Lincoln Savings SEC Bilby, R.M. & Roll, J.M. 21 2 23 0 1996972 Diamond Benefits Life Insurance CONT Strand, R.G. 7 3 7 3 2007995 Western Savings & Loan/RTC SEC McNamee, S.M. 2 17 19 0 2002
1027 Title Search & Examination Services AT McNamee, S.M. 1 1 2 0 19961202 Pillar Point Partners AT & PAT Rosenblatt, P.G. 17 3 20 0 20021541 Allstate Insurance Co. Fair Labor Standards Act Rosenblatt, P.G. 4 1 5 0 20091621 Helicopter Crash Near Meadview, AZ - 8/10/01 Sedwick, J.W. (AK) 1 4 5 0 20061910 Phoenix Licensing, L.L.C., PAT Murguia, M.H. 3 4 6 1 20091977 LifeLock, Inc., Marketing and SP Murguia, M.H. 11 3 14 0 20102039 Sepracor Inc. Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) Campbell, D.G. 1 1 2 0 2010
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 31
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
NINTH CIRCUIT(continued)
971 CALIFORNIA, NORTHERN (66 Litigations)14 Gypsum Wallboard AT Zirpoli, A.J. 51 93 143 1 197815 Hong Kong - 6/30/67 AD Hall, P.M. (CAC) 7 22 22 7 197120 Koratron PAT & AT Renfrew, C.B. 7 13 19 1 197723 Water Meter AT Boldt, G.H. (WAW) 10 23 33 0 197524 Western Liquid Asphalt AT Smith, R.E. (MT) 7 17 24 0 197797 7-Eleven Franchise AT Schnacke, R.H. 7 42 49 0 1975107 Juneau, AK - 9/4/71 AD Hall, P.M. (CAC) 58 12 70 0 1977124 Holiday Magic SEC & AT Burke, L.H. 12 9 16 5 1981143 Great Western Ranches SEC Zirpoli, A.J. 1 3 4 0 1979151 Sta-Power Industries, Inc., SEC & AT Burke, L.H. 6 1 6 1 1981163 IBM Peripheral EDP Devices AT McNichols, R. (ID) 5 6 6 2 1984
(Reassigned to CAN tr'or judges) 0 0 3 0171 Gas Vent Pipe AT Byrne, Jr., W.M. (CAC) 5 9 14 0 1977177 Air West, Inc., SEC Zirpoli, A.J. 8 4 12 0 1980201 Sugar Industry AT Cahn, E.N. 72 45 117 0 1981277 The Gap Stores SEC Williams, S.M. 3 13 16 0 1978338 Airport Car Rental AT Schwarzer, W.W. 9 3 12 0 1984356 Capitol Underwriters SEC Orrick, Jr., W.H. 8 4 12 0 1981369 Data General Corp. AT Patel, M.H. 7 4 11 0 1988386 B.F. Goodrich Passenger Tire AT Ingram, W.A. 2 3 5 0 1986474 Coconut Oil AT Orrick, W.H. 2 3 5 0 1983476 International Total Services, Inc., Schnacke, R.H. 4 1 5 0 1982
Employee Benefit Plan EP512 Prestwich, Scotland - 12/19/79 AD Henderson, T.E. 1 1 2 0 1984550 Long Distance Telephone AT Williams, S.M. 3 1 4 0 1984593 Storage Technology SEC Williams, S.M. 15 6 21 0 1988616 TERA Corp. SEC Orrick, W.H. 1 4 5 0 1986632 San Jose Airport, CA - 6/26/82 AD Patel, M.H. 1 3 4 0 1992682 Super-Premium Ice Cream AT Legge, C.A. 1 4 5 0 1988698 Rexplore, Inc., SEC Jensen, D.L. 23 2 25 0 1992
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 32
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
NINTH CIRCUIT(continued)
710 Spendthrift SEC (No. II) Legge, C.A. 6 9 15 0 1991749 Lothar W. Hubert EP Schwarzer, W.W. 1 1 2 0 1988767 Commercial General Inc. AT Schwarzer, W.W. 16 23 39 0 1989804 Western Monetary SEC Orrick, W.H. 16 3 19 0 1993807 Honolulu, HI - 2/24/89 AD Walker, V.R. 66 39 105 0 1993829 BOC Group PAT Patel, M.H. 8 1 9 0 1993906 Midair Collision Near Tracy, CA - 8/24/89 Smith, F.M. 1 2 3 0 1994965 Omnitrition International SEC Armstrong, S.B. 2 2 4 0 1994993 Clearly Canadian Beverage Corp. SEC Walker, V.R. 1 2 3 0 2000
1011 McLaughlin PAT Ware, J. 4 8 12 0 19991048 Felbatol PL Wilken, C. 31 10 40 1 20001092 Citric Acid AT Smith, F.M. 12 8 20 0 19991114 Louisiana-Pacific Corp. Trade Practices Walker, V.R. 2 1 3 0 19981133 Ford Motor Co. Thick Film Ignition PL Lynch, E.F. 3 0 3 0 20001224 Rational Software Corp. SEC Fogel, J.D. 2 5 7 0 20011226 Sodium Gluconate AT Wilken, C. 2 2 4 0 19991257 CNN & Time Magazine "Operation Tailwind" Fogel, J.D. 6 2 8 0 20071300 Patriot American Hospitality SEC Walker, V.R. 5 4 9 0 20061311 Methionine AT Breyer, C.R. 6 16 21 1 20041316 Charles Schwab & Co., Inc., "Best Execution" SEC Orrick, Jr., W.H. 1 1 2 0 20011319 Nidek Excimer Laser Surgery Systems PAT & AT Breyer, C.R. 4 3 7 0 20031343 Point Mugu, CA - 1/31/00 AD Breyer, C.R. 27 64 90 1 20041347 World War II Era Japanese Forced Labor Walker, V.R. 21 8 29 0 20011369 Napster, Inc., CR Patel, M.H. 9 10 19 0 20081381 Toys R Us, Inc., Privacy Chesney, M.M. 10 3 13 0 20031423 Cygnus Telecommunications Technology, L.L.C., PAT Whyte, R.M. 26 4 30 0 20091527 Cisco Systems, Inc., SEC & DER Ware, J. 1 1 1 1 20071606 Deep Vein Thrombosis Walker, V.R. 18 72 89 1 20081648 Rubber Chemicals AT Chesney, M.M. 5 9 14 0 20091654 Compression Labs, Inc., PAT Fogel, J.D. 7 3 10 0 20071665 Acacia Media Technologies Corp. PAT Ware, J. 20 3 23 0 2010
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 33
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
NINTH CIRCUIT(continued)
1673 Circular Thermostat AT Alsup, W.H. 5 1 6 0 20061754 Apple iPod nano PL Whyte, R.M. 4 4 8 0 20101761 Ditropan XL AT White, J.S. 1 5 6 0 20081793 International Air Transportation Surcharge AT Breyer, C.R. 65 37 102 0 20101809 Terminix EP Armstrong, S.B. 1 1 2 0 20091826 Graphics Processing Units AT Alsup, W.H. 27 27 54 0 20091939 Oilily Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Illston, S.Y. 1 1 2 0 2008
Act (FACTA)
972 CALIFORNIA, EASTERN (3 Litigations)207 Roseville, CA Bomb Disaster - 4/28/73 CD McBride, T.J. 8 116 124 0 1980501 Northern Territory of Australia - 10/6/79 AD Karlton, L.K. 2 1 3 0 1985934 Diamond Match Plant Cleanup Levi, D.F. 1 1 2 0 1996
973 CALIFORNIA, CENTRAL (83 Litigations)25 Concrete Pipe (West of the Rockies) AT Pence, M. (HI) 1 5 6 0 197531 Air Pollution Control Equipment AT Real, M.L. 33 4 37 0 197334 Santa Monica, CA - 1/18/69 AD Pregerson, H. 3 8 11 0 197257 Embro PAT Whelan, F.C. 4 1 5 0 197172 San Antonio, Venezuela - 4/69 AD Kelleher, R.J. 3 1 4 0 197389 Hotel Telephone Charge AT Lucas, M.M. 12 1 13 0 1974103 Toronto International Airport - 7/5/70 AD Hall, P.M. 1 36 36 1 1979106 Duarte, CA - 6/6/71 AD Hall, P.M. 17 56 73 0 1977121 Public Air Travel Tarriff McNichols, R. (ID) 3 2 5 0 1974142 Equity Funding Corp. of America SEC Lucas, M.M. 80 32 107 5 1979150 Petroleum Product AT Gray, W.P. 10 3 13 0 1987172 Paris, France - 3/3/74 AD Real, M.L. 12 203 215 0 1980176 Pago Pago, American Samoa - 1/30/74 AD Byrne, Jr., W.B. 90 51 140 1 1981183 Pennsylvania Life Co. SEC Real, M.L. 9 6 15 0 1981206 Papeete, Tahiti - 7/22/73 AD Real, M.L. 17 11 28 0 1980215 Bali, Indonesia - 4/22/74 AD Williams, D.W. 14 13 27 0 1979239 "Exorcist" CR Williams, D.W. 4 1 5 0 1976274 Doxycycline PAT & AT Pence, M. (HI) 1 1 2 0 1983298 Preferential Drug Products Pricing AT Hill, L. 1 1 2 0 1983309 Sheffield Furniture Corp. PAT Williams, D.W. 6 33 39 0 1981316 Teledyne, Inc., SEC Real, M.L. 2 1 3 0 1978
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 34
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
NINTH CIRCUIT(continued)
355 Vernitron SEC Byrne, Jr., W.M. 5 9 14 0 1982387 California Armored Car AT Hill, I. 5 2 7 0 1982400 California Life Corp. SEC Waters, L.E. 2 7 9 0 1983410 Denver, CO - 11/16/76 AD Kelleher, R.J. 4 1 5 0 1982430 Mt. Erebus, Antarctica - 11/28/79 AD Lucas, M.M. 4 5 9 0 1983445 Mexico City Airport - 10/31/79 AD Waters, L.E. 7 61 68 0 1984482 Kimpo International Airport, Korea AD Hatter, Jr., T.J. 5 14 19 0 1986484 Benson, AZ - 4/8/79 AD Whelan, F.C. 2 2 4 0 1983541 Wellspring Barge SEC Pfaelzer, M.R. 6 1 6 1 1988568 Kenai, AK - 7/14/81 AD Byrne, Jr., W.M. 2 2 4 0 1987569 Covington, KY - 6/2/83 AD Waters, L.E. 43 31 70 4 1988600 Mandell PAT Rafeedie, E. 5 1 6 0 1986629 Motola "Jeannie, Jeannie, Jeannie" CR Rymer, P.A. 10 2 12 0 1991647 National Mortgage Equity SEC Tashima, A.W. 3 6 9 0 1993667 Air Passenger Computer Reservations AT Rafeedie, E. 3 2 5 0 1991695 Honlulu, HI - 11/16/84 Bonner, R. 9 2 5 6 1991700 LA Dept. of Water & Power CONT Gadbois, R.A. 2 1 3 0 1988717 Cerritos, California -- 8/31/86 AD Kenyon, D.V. 13 75 80 0 1999
(Reassigned to CAC tr'or judges) 0 0 8 0726 United Energy Corp. SEC Kenyon, D.V. 2 1 3 0 1992753 Schulman SEC Hauk, A.A. 4 6 10 0 1992809 Burke, Inc., PAT Letts, J.S. 5 2 7 0 1992841 Boardroom Bus. Prod. SEC Real, M.L. 5 1 6 0 1992871 First Executive Corp. SEC Tevrizian, Jr., D.M. 1 11 12 0 1994896 Milli Vanilli Letts, J.S. 2 3 5 0 1993941 Precious Metals SEC Lew, R.S. 4 11 15 0 1999953 U.S. Alcohol Testing of America McLaughlin, L.H. 1 1 2 0 1994901 First Capital Holdings Corp. SEC Davies, J.G. 16 4 20 0 1997908 Bank of Credit and Commerce Marshall, C.B. 5 7 12 0 2000
International Depositors959 Dad's Kid Corp. Baseball Card Rea, W.J. 2 2 4 0 1995
1008 Century 21-RE/MAX Real Estate McLaughlin, L.H. 3 3 3 3 1998Advertising Claims
1009 Castle Energy Corp. SEC Tevrizian, Jr., D.M. 5 1 6 0 19951018 L.A. Gear, Inc., PAT Rea, W.J. 1 1 2 0 1995
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 35
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
NINTH CIRCUIT(continued)
1060 Baxter Healthcare Corp. Gammagard PL Real, M.L. 130 9 136 3 20061082 Citi-Equity Group SEC Manella, N.M. 2 3 5 0 20021106 Comdata Holdings Corp. AT Pfaelzer, M.R. 2 1 3 0 19971136 Connecticut General Life Insurance Co. Hupp, H.L. 2 1 3 0 19981205 Dow Environmental, Inc., Stock Plan Taylor, G.L. 1 1 2 0 19991216 Compact Disc AT Letts, J.S. 2 3 4 1 20051237 Agana, Guam - 8/5/97 AD Hupp, H.L. 37 88 125 0 20031254 FDIC California Property Tax Penalties Hupp, H.L. 21 7 28 0 20021262 Regents of University of CA & IDEXX Pfaelzer, M.R. 1 2 3 0 1999
Laboratories, Inc., PAT1286 Intellectual Property Development, Inc., PAT Pfaelzer, M.R. 12 1 12 1 20001323 Motorcar Parts & Accessories, Inc., SEC Real, M.L. 3 11 14 0 20021327 Mattel, Inc., SEC Pfaelzer, M.R. 4 20 24 0 20041394 Taipei, Taiwan - 10/31/00 AD Feess, G. 9 94 92 0 2005
(Reassigned to CAC tr'or judges) 0 0 11 01451 Capital One Bank Credit Card Terms Baird, L.G. 1 2 2 1 20031475 Heritage Bonds Klausner, R.G. 2 7 9 0 20071483 Qwest Communications Corp. Payphone Hatter, Jr., T.J. 13 23 36 0 2005
Providers Compensation1574 Paxil PL Pfaelzer, M.R. 134 15 147 2 20091581 America Online Spin-Off Accounts Lew, R.S.W. 9 3 12 0 20061601 StarMed Health Personnel, Inc., Fair Labor Real, M.L. 3 3 6 0 2007
Standards Act1610 Conseco Life Insurance Co. Cost of Insurance Matz, A.H. 14 7 21 0 20071671 Reformulated Gasoline (RFG) AT & PAT Snyder, C.A. 7 5 12 0 20091737 American Honda Motor Co., Inc., Oil Filter PL Snyder, C.A. 5 0 5 0 20101803 Banc of America Investment Services, Inc. Stotler, A.H. 4 1 5 0 2008
Overtime Pay1807 Wachovia Securities, LLC, Wage and Hour Carter, D.O. 13 9 22 0 20101822 Bluetooth Headset PL Fischer, D.S. 21 6 27 0 20101864 Charlotte Russe, Inc., Fair and Accurate Credit Klausner, R.G. 2 1 3 0 2008
Transactions Act (FACTA)1897 Mattel, Inc., Toy Lead Paint PL Fischer, D.S. 10 10 20 0 20101926 Halftone Color Separations ('809) PAT Carney, C.J. 5 1 6 0 20101934 Epogen and Aranesp Off-Label Marketing & SP Gutierrez, P.S. 4 1 5 0 20091947 Make-up Art Cosmetics (M.A.C.) Fair and Accurate Pregerson, D.D. 1 2 3 0 2009
Credit Transactions Act (FACTA)
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 36
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
NINTH CIRCUIT(continued)
974 CALIFORNIA, SOUTHERN (11 Litigations)161 U.S. Financial SEC Turrentine, H.B. 12 9 21 0 1981513 Wickes Co. SEC Enright, W.B. 1 7 8 0 1985514 Nucorp Energy Inc., SEC Irving, J.L. 9 9 18 0 1991653 American Principal SEC Thompson, Jr., G. 8 28 36 0 1992783 U.S. Grant Hotel SEC Enright, W.B. 32 1 33 0 1992
1094 Roller Hockey League Moskowitz, B.T. 1 1 2 0 19981109 Manufacturers Life Insurance Co. Premium Moskowitz, B.T. 13 2 15 0 20011296 Alliance Equipment Lease Program SEC Jones, Jr., N.A. 26 1 26 1 20091405 California Wholesale Electricity AT Whaley, R.H. (WAE) 22 8 30 0 20071751 Jamster Marketing Miller, J.T. 3 3 5 1 20101806 Morgan Stanley & Co., Inc., Overtime Pay (No. II) Benitez, R.T. 8 3 11 0 2010
975 HAWAII (3 Litigations)303 Hawaiian Hotel Room Rate AT King, S.P. 4 1 5 0 1978763 FPI/Agretech SEC Real, M.L. (CAC) 8 5 13 0 1991840 Estate of Ferdinand E. Marcos Human Rights Real, M.L. (CAC) 2 5 7 0 1995
976 IDAHO (2 Litigations)167 Peruvian Road McNichols, R. 2 2 4 0 1983
1215 Albertson's, Inc., EP Winmill, B.L. 4 5 9 0 2001
977 MONTANA (2 Litigations)648 Montana Power SEC Lovell, C.C. 3 0 3 0 1986
1054 Billings, MT - 12/18/92 AD Shanstrom, J.D. 1 5 5 1 1997
978 NEVADA (7 Litigations)450 "Santa Barbara Like It Is Today" Photograph Foley, R.D. 34 1 35 0 1982453 MGM Grand Hotel-Las Vegas - 11/21/80 CD Bechtle, L.C. (PAE) 89 340 429 0 1985686 Republic Mineral SEC George, L.D. 2 2 4 0 1992
1201 Delgratia Mining Corp. SEC Pro, P.M. 2 0 2 0 20001406 California Retail Natural Gas & Electricity AT Pro, P.M. 9 0 9 0 20021619 Musha Cay Dawson, K.J. 2 1 3 0 20101735 Wal-Mart Wage and Hour EP Pro, P.M. 29 13 42 0 2010
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 37
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
NINTH CIRCUIT(continued)
979 OREGON (2 Litigations)329 Petrol Stops Northwest EP Belloni, R.C. 4 1 5 0 1979537 Federal Bank & Trust Co., Ltd., SEC Redden, J.A. 2 1 3 0 1985
980 WASHINGTON, EASTERN (1 Litigation)1375 Windflower Farms, Inc., PAT Shea, E.F. 2 2 4 0 2002
981 WASHINGTON, WESTERN (20 Litigations)114 Atlantic City, NJ - 7/26/69 AD Goodwin, W.N. 6 1 7 0 1976128 Boise Cascade SEC Sharp, M.E. 1 5 6 0 1977146 West Coast Bakery Flour AT Boldt, G.H. 3 1 4 0 1977178 Mack Truck, Inc., AT Voorhees, D.S. 2 1 3 0 1979249 Bristol Bay, AK Salmon Fishery AT Fitzgerald, J.M. (AK) 2 5 4 3 1984317 Sunstrand Data Control, Inc., PAT Fitzgerald, J.M. (AK) 5 0 5 0 1981359 Bombay, India - 1/1/78 AD Fitzgerald, J.M. (AK) 179 0 179 0 1985551 Washington Public Power Supply SEC Browning, W.D. (AZ) 12 21 32 1 1995823 Fidata Trust Co. of New York Collection Bryan, R.J. 14 0 14 0 1991855 Alaska Electrical Pension Coughenour, J.C. 2 0 2 0 2000988 Washington/Ohio State Pension Zilly, T.S. 2 4 5 1 1994
1017 M/V HANJIN SEATTLE Cargo Losses Dwyer, W.L. 6 3 9 0 19971199 Ford Motor Co./Citibank Cardholder Rebate Dwyer, W.L. 5 1 6 0 20001276 Palembang, Indonesia - 12/19/97 (No. II) AD Coughenour, J.C. 26 7 30 3 20061346 Amazon.com, Inc./Alexa Internet Privacy Pechman, M.J. 1 3 4 0 20011407 Phenylpropanolamine (PPA) PL Rothstein, B.J. 1,835 1,550 2,897 488 20091418 Burlington Northern & Santa Fe Railway Co. Pechman, M.J. 2 3 5 0 2005
Employee Agreements1549 Mailblocks, Inc., PAT Coughenour, J.C. 1 1 2 0 20051896 General Motors Corp. Speedometer PL Coughenour, J.C. 3 1 3 1 20091937 United States Postal Service Privacy Act Robart, J.L. 1 1 2 0 2009
TOTAL 4,300 4,105 7,850 555
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 38
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
TENTH CIRCUIT1082 COLORADO (12 Litigations)
79 King Resources SEC Finesilver, S.G. 7 2 6 3 197888 Denver, CO - 10/3/69 AD Winner, F.M. 3 1 2 2 1978335 Stapleton International Airport in Finesilver, S.G. 6 0 6 0 1979
Denver, CO - 8/7/75 AD630 Storage Technology Corp. SEC Finesilver, S.G. 2 13 15 0 1991646 Petro-Lewis SEC Carrigan, J.R. 21 1 18 4 1991711 Dow "Sarabond" PL Matsch, R.P. 12 12 15 9 1996751 Denver, CO - 11/15/87 AD Finesilver, J.G. 31 17 38 10 1991798 Mountain States EP Finesilver, S.G. 15 13 28 0 1990915 Alert Income Partners SEC Weinshienk, Z.L. 9 13 22 0 1998
1022 Colorado Springs, CO - 3/3/91 AD Nottingham, E.W. 11 0 10 1 19991139 Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., EP Weinshienk, Z.L. 1 4 5 0 20031788 Qwest Communications International, Inc. Blackburn, R.E. 4 26 30 0 2009
SEC & "ERISA" (No. II)
1083 KANSAS (12 Litigations)22 Grain Shipments CONT Templar, G. 49 17 62 4 1973112 Silver Plume, CO - 10/2/70 AD Theis, F.G. 7 10 17 0 1978137 Clinton Oil Co. SEC Brown, W.E. & Rogers, R.D. 9 2 11 0 1979149 Natural Resources, Inc., SEC Rogers, R.D. 5 1 6 0 1981211 A.H. Robins Co., Inc., "Dalkon Shield" PL Theis, F.G. 1,085 51 531 593 1987
(Reassigned to KS tr'or judges) 0 0 12 0255 FMC Corp. PAT O'Conner, E.E. 3 2 5 0 1977378 Dept. of Energy Stripper Well Exemption Theis, F.G. 22 16 35 3 1981468 Termination of Speed Queen Distributorships Kelly, P.F. 6 1 2 5 1984
1021 Xerox Independent Service Organizations AT Vratil, K.H. 1 1 1 1 20001249 Baseball Bat AT Vratil, K.H. 2 1 2 1 20001468 Universal Service Fund Telephone Billing Practices Lungstrum, J.W. 64 4 68 0 20091853 The TJX Companies, Inc., Fair and Accurate Vratil, K.H. 9 1 10 0 2008
Credit Transactions Act (FACTA)
1084 NEW MEXICO (2 Litigations)403 New Mexico Natural Gas AT Winder, D.K. 1 4 5 0 1983
1050 Psychiatric Hospitals Loan Financing CONT Conway, J.E. 3 6 9 0 1996
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 39
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
TENTH CIRCUIT(continued)
1085 OKLAHOMA, NORTHERN (4 Litigations)153 Home Stake Production Co. SEC Real, M.L. (CAC) 3 29 32 0 1990233 Palizzio, Inc., AT Cook, H.D. 3 2 5 0 1976407 Van Cleve, MS - 8/13/77 AD Cook, H.D. 7 3 10 0 1981
1252 Multimedia Games, Inc., SEC Holmes, S.E. 1 1 2 0 2001
1086 OKLAHOMA, EASTERN (1 Litigation)11 Ardmore, OK - 4/22/66 AD Langely, E. 7 16 21 2 1972
1087 OKLAHOMA, WESTERN (9 Litigations)55 Four Seasons SEC Laws Thomsen, R.C. (MD) 31 1 29 3 1979129 Wheat Farmers AT Daugherty, F.A. 5 1 6 0 1979339 First National Bank Heavener, OK SEC Thompson, R.G. 1 1 2 0 1979452 Wheat Farmers Class Action AT (No. II) Daugherty, F.A. 1 1 2 0 1983525 Longhorn SEC Eubanks, L.B. 79 13 92 0 1985585 Invoil SEC Eubanks, L.B. 7 16 22 1 1987604 Texas International SEC Russell, D.L. 5 5 10 0 1993718 Savings Investment Service Corp. Loan Commitment Weiner, C.R. (PAE) 14 7 18 3 1991
1600 General Motors Corp. "Piston Slap" PL Heaton, J.L. 11 2 13 0 2007
1088 UTAH (3 Litigations)595 Diversified Energy Corp. SEC Anderson, A.J. 7 3 3 7 1986
1093 Commercial Explosives AT Sam, D. 20 2 22 0 20021546 Medical Waste Services AT Kimball, D.A. 5 3 8 0 2010
1089 WYOMING (2 Litigations)1013 Copley Pharmaceutical, Inc., "Albuterol" PL Brimmer, C.A. 117 1 118 0 20031293 Natural Gas Royalties Qui Tam Downes, W.F. 67 16 81 2 2008
TOTAL 1,779 342 1,467 654
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 40
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
1126 ALABAMA, NORTHERN (6 Litigations)81 Cast Iron Pipe AT Pointer, Jr., S.C. 33 10 43 0 1977522 Chihuahua, Mexico - 7/27/81 AD Propst, R.B. 1 2 3 0 1984926 Silicone Gel Breast Implants PL Nelson, E.L. 26,465 961 22,198 5,228 2003
1103 Ford Motor Co. Head Rest PL Pointer, Jr., S.C. 1 1 2 0 19991635 Dollar General Corp. Fair Labor Standards Act Clemon, U.W. 3 1 4 0 20061985 Total Body Formula PL Proctor, R.D. 16 21 37 0 2010
1127 ALABAMA, MIDDLE (1 Litigation)1130 Consolidated "Non-Filing Insurance" Fee Clemon, U.W. (ALN) 19 7 23 3 2005
1128 ALABAMA, SOUTHERN (4 Litigations)351 Hale County, AL - 11/15/77 AD Pittman, V. 1 6 7 0 1979923 Barge GULF FLEET 265 - 12/90 Butler, Jr., C.R. 4 1 5 0 1996
1003 Amtrak "Sunset Limited" Train Crash in Vollmer, Jr., R.W. 15 98 113 0 2001Bayou Canot, AL - 9/22/93 CD
1165 Residential Telephone Lease Program CONT Butler, Jr., C.R. 5 1 5 1 2001
1129 FLORIDA, NORTHERN (5 Litigations)822 Fairchild Industries, Inc., "ERISA" Vinson, C.R. 1 1 2 0 1993878 Infant Formula AT Paul, M.M. 25 2 27 0 1994
1189 Commercial Tissue Products AT Paul, M.M. 11 30 41 0 20011331 Nicaraguan Contra/Narcotics Trafficking Paul, M.M. 7 1 8 0 20031519 The Progressive Corp. Insurance Underwriting Paul, M.M. 7 1 8 0 2007
& Rating Practices
113A FLORIDA, MIDDLE (12 Litigations)70 Cross-Florida Barge Canal Bechtle, L.C. (PAE) 1 4 5 0 1981640 Jacksonville, FL - 12/6/84 AD Kovachevich, E.A. 5 7 12 0 1988892 Scientology Flag Service Org./IRS FOIA Hodges, W.T. 10 21 31 0 1993940 Carbon Dioxide Industry AT Beer, P. (LAE) 15 9 24 0 1996
1030 Disposable Contact Lens AT Schlesinger, H..E. 7 11 18 0 20031118 Recomm International Display, Inc., CONT Beer, P. (LAE) 173 102 128 144 2002
(Reassigned to FLM tr'or judge) 0 0 3 01404 Philadelphia Life Insurance Co. Sales Practices Fawsett, P.C. 1 1 2 0 20031510 Daewoo Motor co., Ltd., Dealerships Presnell, G.A. 42 1 43 0 2005
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 41
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
ELEVENTH CIRCUIT(continued)
1624 GMAC Insurance Management Corp. Schlesinger, H.E. 1 1 2 0 2007Overtime Pay
1656 CP Ships Ltd. SEC Whittemore, J.D. 4 3 7 0 20071698 American General Life & Accident Insurance Co. Adams, Jr., H.L. 78 2 80 0 2009
Retiree Benefits "ERISA"1828 Imagitas, Inc., Drivers' Privacy Protection Act Corrigan, T.J. 11 2 13 0 2010
113C FLORIDA, SOUTHERN (25 Litigations)48 Maracaibo, Venezuela - 3/16/69 AD Atkins, C.C. 4 7 11 0 197182 Yarn Processing PAT Atkins, C.C. 26 64 85 5 1988120 Nissan Motor Corp. AT Atkins, C.C. 23 1 24 0 1982139 Florida Everglades - 12/29/72 AD Fay, P.T. 27 38 57 8 1974162 Bestline Products SEC & AT Marcus, S. 11 2 2 11 1987218 National Airlines, Inc., Maternity Roettger, Jr., N.C. 1 4 5 0 1977
Leave Practice259 Florida Real Estate SEC Roettger, Jr., N.C. 1 11 12 0 1980354 Sinking of Motor Vessel UKOLA Atkins, C.C. 10 3 13 0 1984519 First State SEC Atkins, C.C. 1 4 2 1 1987575 Eastern Airlines Engine Failure Davis, E.B. 3 24 27 0 1987
Miami, FL - 5/5/83 AD (Reassigned to FLS tr'or judge) 0 0 2 0701 Bradford Trust SEC Gonzalez, Jr., J.A. 5 28 33 0 1988947 Cascade International SEC Nesbitt, L.C. 1 17 18 0 2000
1000 Southeast Banking Corp. SEC & Loan Moore, K.M. 1 7 8 0 2002Loss Reserves
1079 MultiVest Options Commodities SEC Ungaro-Benages, U. 1 1 2 0 19991125 Cali, Colombia - 12/20/95 AD Moore, K.M. 30 206 236 0 20021131 Florida Everglades - 5/11/96 AD Davis, E.B. 12 46 58 0 20001141 Phonometrics, Inc., Electronic Long Distance Ryskamp, K.L. 1 21 21 1 2004
Call Cost Computer/Recorder PAT1152 Isuzu Trooper PL Moore, K.M. 4 2 6 0 19981173 American Airlines Flight 869 - 1/17/96 AD Tjoflat, G.B. (11th Circuit) 10 4 12 2 20021243 Skin Cap PL Graham, D.L. 47 4 51 0 20031297 Sunbeam Corp. SEC Middlebrooks, D.M. 2 23 25 0 20031317 Terazosin Hydrochloride AT Seitz, P.A. 17 7 23 1 20051341 America Online, Inc., Version 5.0 Software Gold, A.S. 41 6 47 0 20031504 U-Haul International, Inc., Moving Equipment Hurley, D.T.K. 1 5 6 0 2004
Rental AT2005 Tegucigalpa, Honduras - 5/30/08 AD Gold, A.S. 1 1 1 1 2010
Multidistrict Litigation Terminated Through September 30, 2010 Page 42
Actions TerminatedTr'e Dist MDL MDL Caption Transferee Judge Total Tr'd Total Filed Dis'd Rem'd Year of
No. in Tr'e Court Termination
ELEVENTH CIRCUIT(continued)
113E GEORGIA, NORTHERN (18 Litigations)220 Ryder Truck Lines EP Moye, Jr., C.A. 6 2 2 6 1981237 Chicken "Broiler" AT O'Kelley, W.C. 9 25 34 0 1987318 Armored Car AT Freeman, R.C. 10 7 17 0 1979320 New Hope, GA - 4/4/77 AD Moye, Jr., C.A. 5 76 81 0 1981861 Domestic Air Transportation AT Shoob, M.H. 36 6 42 0 1993862 Practice Management Associates, Inc., CONT Tidwell, G.E. 30 5 35 0 1996930 New Brunswick, GA - 4/5/91 O'Kelley, W.C. 14 3 16 0 1995
(Reassigned to GAN tr'or judge) 0 0 1 01075 Polypropylene Carpet AT Murphy, H.L. 4 16 20 0 20011099 Carrollton, GA - 8/21/95 AD Evans, O.D. 8 6 12 2 19971212 Motorsports Merchandise AT Thrash, Jr., T.W. 1 3 4 0 20011274 Gemstar Development Corp. PAT Hunt, Jr., W.B. 5 8 13 0 20051342 Cigarette AT Forrester, J.O. 5 4 9 0 20031377 Dippin' Dots, Inc., PAT Thrash, Jr., T.W. 7 1 6 2 20041424 Delta Airlines, Inc., "ERISA" Carnes, J.E. 5 0 5 0 20061467 Tri-State Crematory Murphy, H.L. 1 5 5 1 20051517 Gator Corporation Software TDMK & CR Forrester, J.O. 12 2 13 1 20051895 LTL Shipping Services AT Duffey, Jr., W.S. 49 2 51 0 20092035 RBS Worldpay, Inc., Customer Data Security Breach Pannell, Jr., C.A. 1 1 2 0 2010
113J GEORGIA, SOUTHERN (2 Litigations)1435 Wireless Telephone Replacement Protection Edenfield, B.A. 2 1 3 0 2002
Programs1677 NovaStar Home Mortgage Inc. Mortgage Moore, Jr., W.T. 1 2 3 0 2008
Lending Practices
TOTAL 27,454 2,019 24,055 5,418